3 reviews

You Belong Here Now: A Novel
by Dianna Rostad

Published: 2021-04-06T00:0
Paperback : 368 pages
11 members reading this now
11 clubs reading this now
4 members have read this book
Recommended to book clubs by 3 of 3 members
“It’s so hard to believe that this is a debut novel! It’s an historic novel. Talk about hitting me on so many good points.” –John Busbee, The Culture Buzz, weekly on www.KFMG.org

“Set against the harsh backdrop of Montana, You Belong Here Now is a novel as straightforward ...

No other editions available.
Add to Club Selections
Add to Possible Club Selections
Add to My Personal Queue
Jump to


“It’s so hard to believe that this is a debut novel! It’s an historic novel. Talk about hitting me on so many good points.” –John Busbee, The Culture Buzz, weekly on www.KFMG.org

“Set against the harsh backdrop of Montana, You Belong Here Now is a novel as straightforward and powerful as the characters who populate it. I love this book, and I guarantee you won’t find a finer debut work anywhere.” — William Kent Krueger, New York Times bestselling author of This Tender Land

“You Belong Here Now distills the essence of the American spirit in this uplifting story. Perfect for book clubs looking to discuss the true meaning of family.” — Kathleen Grissom, New York Times bestselling author of The Kitchen House

In this brilliant debut reminiscent of William Kent Krueger's This Tender Land and Lisa Wingate's Before We Were Yours, three orphans journey westward from New York City to the Big Sky Country of Montana, hoping for a better life where beautiful wild horses roam free.

Montana 1925: Three brave kids from New York board the orphan train headed west. An Irish boy who lost his whole family to Spanish flu, a tiny girl who won’t talk, and a volatile young man who desperately needs to escape Hell’s Kitchen. They are paraded on platforms across the Midwest to work-worn folks and journey countless miles, racing the sun westward. Before they reach the last rejection and stop, the kids come up with a daring plan, and they set off toward the Yellowstone River and grassy mountains where the wild horses roam.

Fate guides them toward the ranch of a family stricken by loss. Broken and unable to outrun their pasts in New York, the family must do the unthinkable in order to save them.

Nara, the daughter of a successful cattleman, has grown into a brusque spinster who refuses the kids on sight. She’s worked hard to gain her father’s respect and hopes to run their operation, but if the kids stay, she’ll be stuck in the kitchen.

Nara works them without mercy, hoping they’ll run off, but they buck up and show spirit, and though Nara will never be motherly, she begins to take to them. So, when Charles is jailed for freeing wild horses that were rounded up for slaughter, and an abusive mother from New York shows up to take the youngest, Nara does the unthinkable, risking everything she holds dear to change their lives forever.

“From the moment the reader steps on the train with these orphaned children, You Belong Here Now shows how beauty can emerge from even the darkest places.” —Erika Robuck, national bestselling author of Hemingway’s Girl

“Rostad’s bighearted debut is full of surprises, and warm with wisdom about what it means to be family.” —Meg Waite Clayton, New York Times bestselling author of The Last Train to London

Editorial Review

No Editorial Review Currently Available


She drove the cart gently, while her eyes roamed the familiar folds of her family’s ranch. Sagebrush cleaved to the sandy soil and ponderosa pines huddled together in the chalky mountains that surrounded their vast range. Papa usually had a little something laid aside whenever anyone went belly-up, and over the years he’d built up quite a reputation as the largest stock operation in the county. You couldn’t see from one end to the other on the Stewart Ranch. ... view entire excerpt...

Discussion Questions

1. What do you think the wild horses represent or symbolize in the book?
2. Charles protects Patrick from racist slurs at school by filling Billy’s mouth with dirt and holding it closed. If Charles were your son, how would you handle correcting him while acknowledging his courage to stand up to a bully?
3. The ranch hand who pulled up Opal’s dress was viciously beaten by Charles. Neither went to jail. Is it okay to use violence as a form of punishment, protection, or justice?
4. Do you think Papa should have taken a stand against the people who slurred Patrick rather than encouraging him to hide his Irish lilt?
5. When Patrick prayed and made the sign of the cross against his chest, how different were the reactions of Mama and Papa Stewart to his Catholicism? Were they substantially different?
6. Charles and Patrick go about things very differently and have unlike dispositions. Why do you think this is? How does it inform the way they see and treat animals? Their horses?
7. Nara’s actions towards the kids are unmaternal at best. How does it contrast with her behavior toward the little horse caught on the fence? Did you think she’d ever make a good mother to the three orphans?
8. Nara tells her father that she wants Jim their Cheyenne ranch hand to be foreman. Papa says, “Ain’t nobody gonna listen to an Injun.” Was his reply racist or just representative of 1925 and the reality of that time?
9. Should Nara have been braver and admitted that she liked Jim romantically? Did Nara’s unwillingness to admit that she was interested in Jim, make you believe she was prejudiced?
10. Mama Stewart usually has something to say about everything, so when she noticed Nara’s interest in Jim, why do you think Mama Stewart didn’t say anything—even to Nara?
11. Jim clearly tries to fit into the world beyond the reservation by how he dresses and cuts his hair, but ultimately, did it do him any good? If you were Jim, would you have gone back to the reservation?
12. If it’s the only way to raise livestock, do you think it’s okay to round up wild mustangs and use them for chicken feed to preserve forage for human food production? What would you rather see happen?
13. Were the children of this day and time better left in orphanages and asylums in New York or sent out on the train to the farms and ranches? Overall, do you think the orphan train is a better adoption program/foster care system than we have today? How would you compare them?
14. Should Opal’s mother have been allowed to take her back after Opal ran away numerous times? If that happened today, what would the response be from our social services do you think? The Stewarts fake Opal’s death and hide her from her mother. Was it the right thing to do for Opal? What would you have done?
15. Ivar is clearly under financial duress yet refuses to accept monetary reparation for the mustangs Patrick sets free. Why? How do you think this staunch individualism manifests in our culture and politics today?
16. Do you think Mama Stewart was happy in her marital/family role? How does Nara’s attitude about womens’ roles play into her mother’s happiness in the story?
17. Charles was jailed for freeing the wild horses, though Patrick committed the crime. Would you have freed the mustangs? Do you feel it was a crime?
18. How does Nara’s attitude towards right and wrong differ from Charles’s? How do these two views converge in the book?
19. The State Trooper disobeyed a bench order and left without exhuming Opal’s body. Was justice served when the trooper refused to enforce the judge’s order? By what measurement or process can we effect justice in our world?

Notes From the Author to the Bookclub

No notes at this time.

Book Club Recommendations

Member Reviews

Overall rating:
by Grace D. (see profile) 02/20/23

  "A heartbreaking bit of history"by Gail R. (see profile) 03/22/22

You Belong Here Now, Dianna Rostad, author; Courtney Patterson, narrator
The year is 1925 and a train is carrying orphans from New York to Montana, making several stops on the way. At each
... (read more)

  "The Harshness of the 1920’s"by liz p. (see profile) 01/22/22

Three young children are alone with no family. The orphans are placed on a train in New York bound for Montana. They hope to be adopted along the way. Unfortunately for the children there i... (read more)

  "A very touching book"by Elizabeth P. (see profile) 09/08/21

Only three children left on an orphan train heading west.

We know we aren’t going to get picked. What should we do?

What they do is jump from the train.

Charles, Patrick, and O

... (read more)

by Kim R. S. (see profile) 08/24/21

Rate this book
Remember me

Now serving over 80,000 book clubs & ready to welcome yours. Join us and get the Top Book Club Picks of 2022 (so far).



Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...