1 review

A Dual Inheritance: A Novel
by Joanna Hershon

Published: 2013-05-07
Hardcover : 496 pages
3 members reading this now
2 clubs reading this now
0 members have read this book
For readers of Rules of Civility and The Marriage Plot, Joanna Hershon’s A Dual Inheritance is an engrossing novel of passion, friendship, betrayal, and class—and their reverberations across generations.
Autumn 1962: Ed Cantowitz and Hugh Shipley meet in their final year at ...
No other editions available.
Add to Club Selections
Add to Possible Club Selections
Add to My Personal Queue
Jump to


For readers of Rules of Civility and The Marriage Plot, Joanna Hershon’s A Dual Inheritance is an engrossing novel of passion, friendship, betrayal, and class—and their reverberations across generations.
Autumn 1962: Ed Cantowitz and Hugh Shipley meet in their final year at Harvard. Ed is far removed from Hugh’s privileged upbringing as a Boston Brahmin, yet his drive and ambition outpace Hugh’s ambivalence about his own life. These two young men form an unlikely friendship, bolstered by a fierce shared desire to transcend their circumstances. But in just a few short years, not only do their paths diverge—one rising on Wall Street, the other becoming a kind of global humanitarian—but their friendship ends abruptly, with only one of them understanding why.
Can a friendship define your view of the world? Spanning from the Cuban Missile Crisis to the present-day stock market collapse, with locations as diverse as Dar es Salaam, Boston, Shenzhen, and Fishers Island, A Dual Inheritance asks this question, as it follows not only these two men, but the complicated women in their vastly different lives. And as Ed and Hugh grow farther and farther apart, they remain uniquely—even surprisingly—connected.
Praise for A Dual Inheritance
“The best book about male friendship written this young century.”Details
“[An] engrossing saga.”Vogue
“Hershon artfully guides us through the lives of Ed and Hugh, college buddies who meet at Harvard in the ’60s, shifting between their perspectives through adulthood to detail their lingering impact on one another’s lives in such a way that it’ll make you take a second look at all of your relationships.”GQ
“Let this story of two Harvard men’s unexpected friendship and its sudden end transport you through time (beginning on Harvard’s campus in 1962) and place.”—The Huffington Post
“A richly composed . . . portrait of familial gravity and the wobbly orbits that bring us together again and again.”Kirkus Reviews
“This thought-provoking generational tale is a heartfelt and beautiful story of an unlikely friendship that fades at times, but never seems to go away.”Long Island Press

“Sharply observed and masterfully constructed, Hershon’s fourth novel is her strongest yet, a deft and assured examination of ambition, envy, longing, and kinship.”Booklist (starred review)
“Hershon deftly explores how individuals often sabotage their chances for happiness. . . . The characters in this novel are fully realized, the story moves along at a fast pace, and the author is well informed about her subject. Highly recommended.”Library Journal (starred review)
“[A] searing novel about class, ethnicity, and love . . . The intensely detailed love triangle is reminiscent of an East Coast elite answer to the Midwestern trio of Freedom, but with mere keen observation in place of that other novel’s sweeping moral pronouncements. Hershon explores the ways we can, and can’t, escape our backgrounds.”Publishers Weekly (starred review)

Editorial Review

A Guest Review of â??A Dual Inheritance,â?? by Joanna Hershon

By Meg Wolitzer

Meg Wolitzer

Meg Wolitzer's novels include The Interestings; The Uncoupling; The Ten-Year Nap; The Position; and The Wife. She is also the author of a novel for young readers, The Fingertips of Duncan Dorfman. Wolitzer's short fiction has appeared in The Best American Short Stories and The Pushcart Prize. In September 2013, along with singer-songwriter Suzzy Roche, she will be a guest artist in the Princeton Atelier program at Princeton University.

To open a novel when your characters are in college is to invite the reader into a world thatâ??s just beginning. In her excellent new novel, A Dual Inheritance, Joanna Hershon offers up two protagonists, Ed and Hugh, a Jew and a WASP, two men with very different economic and cultural backgrounds, sensibilities and internal compasses, at the exact moment when they first meet at Harvard in 1962. Her observations of college life in that era are casually and unselfconsciously rendered:

â??They went to Adams House and drank gin with limes, and Ed met the head of the drama club and a Crimson writer whose work he admired. Ed watched as girls approached Hugh and Hugh ignored their not-so-subtle invitations. Ed marveled at how, like preening birds, they offered their pale necks, their bosoms, arranged their jewelry to catch the light as if lighting were the issue.â??

But this is not a college novel at all, and in fact Harvard is just the springboard to many other places, among them Africa, Haiti and Shenzhen, China, all rendered with authenticity and lightness of touch. Itâ??s a pleasure to see such a close-grained writer use the world as freely as her characters do, and not feel compelled to huddle in a small square of real estate, somehow thinking that thatâ??s the best way to emphasize her protagonistsâ?? interior lives. Interior and exterior lives are given equal shrift here, in a novel that is both psychologically complex and observant in matters of place and time. The latter becomes important as Hershon ambitiously powers her two men across not just continents but also across decades.

A novel of friendship can be harder to pull off than, say, a family novel, in which the charactersâ?? connection is readymade, and it isnâ??t all that hard to arrange to put two people in the same room every once in a while (think holidays). Though in real life, friends can go a very long time without seeing each other, and though a relationship can shift overtly or microscopically, only a patient, knowing writer allows herself to take the time needed to approximate the rhythms of a long and complicated friendship.

Itâ??s wonderful to see a novelist give her characters lives that are messy and let them engage in relationships that can be baffling. Thereâ??s a love triangle here, and a satisfying generational storyline. Neither Hugh nor Ed are given the â??curfewâ?? that a more anxious and intrusive writer might insist upon as a way to control the narrative. Instead, they are allowed to unspool, revealing themselves to the reader slowly, subtly, over the course of this observant novel of friendship, love, class and fate.

Joanna Hershon on A Dual Inheritance

Joanna Hershon

Iâ??ve always been fascinated by distinct places and periods of time in which unlikely friendships are possible. My last novel was about German settlers in the American Southwest during the mid-1800s. During the writing process, I realized that what compelled me most about this time and place was not just the historical details--so fascinating and unlike our modern existence--but what fertile ground it was for improbable relationships to blossom.

The protagonists of my new novel, A Dual Inheritance, meet in a more prosaic way--at college--than did those 19th century pioneers, but Harvard in the early 1960s had its own set of charms and challenges. Because of their wildly different backgrounds, issues of class and money beset best friends Ed Cantowitz and Hugh Shipley, though more salient is how they both identify as outsiders. But what happens to such a bond over time? How much do their different backgrounds ultimately matter?

Their story takes the reader all over the globe (Dar es Salaam, Shenzhen, Haiti; the wilds of Wall Street) and spans two generations, encompassing a cast of characters to whom I hope youâ??ll grow just attached as I have. This is the story of two lives converging andâ??just as quicklyâ??diverging; itâ??s the surprising, even shocking reverberations of one brief friendship.


No Excerpt Currently Available

Discussion Questions

No discussion questions at this time.

Notes From the Author to the Bookclub

No notes at this time.

Book Club Recommendations

Member Reviews

Overall rating:
by Heather J. (see profile) 09/19/14

This book spans nearly five decades, traverses several countries and follows two generations. The first two-thirds follow Hugh, Ed and Helen-- their years through college, and the years foll... (read more)

  "Stereotypical, boring characters!"by Yvonne O. (see profile) 11/14/13

Rate this book
Remember me

Now serving over 80,000 book clubs & ready to welcome yours. Join us and get the Top Book Club Picks of 2022 (so far).



Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...