The book had a lot of potential but fell flat. Georgie is annoying and Neal is a drip. I had high expectations for this book but was very disappointed.

Our club did not like the book at all. We were curious to read something by Rainbow Rowell, but this was not the one! Went round and round without much point, and the insertion of this magical phone element only confused the story more! We just didn't care about these characters.

Good read. Light and humorous

Unusual.