Sugar elicited a lively discussion and strong sentiments about content and structure by book club members. There are many themes to this book including incest and child abuse. It also explores the political and cultural realities of state where a small group of people hold all the power.

The storyline was clear to all readers despite the liberal use of flashbacks.

One member did not think that the male author was able to write a convincing female voice for the female main character. She also felt that this woman would never have been able to be the mayor with her character flaws and lack of political support.

Interesting connection between the personal story and the sugar industry with the quotes at the beginning of each chapter from the book "King Cane."