its always interesting to read others reviews after I have finished a book - - so i can agree with some of the constructive criticism and the raves. I totally enjoy this author so was excited to get this book to read and I wasn't disappointed. While I agree it might not be the best one to describe the tragic occurrences during that time, it was still an excellent story. and there were still twists at the end that I did not anticipate.....a good read.