I thought the book was beautifully written and very visual and for that reason I cannot give it a bad review. I just think this book isn't for everyone. If you really love fantasy you may love this book, although it did lack something in the story line. Most of our book club was not happy with the ending and I thought the whole idea of the book was a bit silly, but then again I am not a big fantasy reader. Based on how imaginitive and visual the writing was I definitely would have liked to visit The Night Circus!