Member Profile

Name : Suzanne M.

My Reviews

 
Slow, Boring, Interesting
Mysteries of Pittsburgh

Arthur has one last chance to live a carefree summer before he gets a serious job and has to be responsible. He is also trying to keep a low profile about his family lineage … his father is involved in the Jewish Mafia. As the story begins he is introduced to some intriguing characters at a party. He becomes friendly with Art and a girl named Phlox. Things get complicated when Arthur begins dating Phlox and Art develops a jealousy. It is soon obvious that Art is in love with Arthur. Arthur who admires Art's style becomes curious about same-sex affairs. This tryst doesn't last long, since Phlox isn't willing to share Arthur. Jane is the beautiful sophisticated type and seemingly mismatched to Cleveland. She doesn't interact much with the story, but often appears in the thoughts of the male characters. Cleveland drives a motorcycle … a tough guy who makes money as a collector for loan sharks. Cleveland wants to escalate his status as a criminal and is trying to join the mafia. He wants Arthur to connect him with the higher echelons in his father’s crime organization.

There are some descriptive scenes that I found to be a bit raunchy and lost interest in the story at several points. I think Chabon spent too much time on character development and less on plot development. Even so, Chabon does know how to weave characters and motives together despite their differences. I read from the author’s notes on the book that his inspiration was Fitzgerald’s “The Great Gatsby” and parts of his story were loosely autobiographical. Having only seen the movie on Fitzgerald’s book, I am even more intrigued and will definitely read the novel it was based on. One redeeming statement Arthur makes at the end of Chabon’s novel is that he tends to exaggerate greatly. With that in mind, I can imagine that Arthur’s thoughts and actions were amplified to add shock value. Maybe Chabon thinks this technique will lure in readers, but for me I was left disgusted more than once.

 
Book Club Recommended
Fun, Adventurous, Interesting
Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie

Flavia is a precocious 11 year-old girl who finds herself in the middle of murder mystery. She knows where to go for answers ... the library. After researching the victim's history at the library she uncovers a scandal over a missing valuable stamp. Her thoughts analyze details of events leading up to the discovery of a dying man, and her father's penchant for stamps collecting. The family cook has just made a fresh custard pie and left it to cool, when one piece is mysteriously missing. Another fatality surfaces when a dead snipe is found on the front doorstep with a stamp stuck to its bill. Flavia schemes throughout to clear her father's name when he is accused. She even tries to take the blame herself, after all she was the one who discovered the body. She is obsessed with chemistry and uses her knowledge of chemical reactions to help determine the cause of death. She is brave and faces evil as she begins to unravel the mystery of the murder. In the end she learns a lot about her father and feels that their father-daughter relationship has reached another level.

I don't know if I got the title's connection to the overall story. I think I have a hang-up about titles and look for ways they can sum up the essence of a book. Sometimes titles are metaphors for a story's message. Maybe titles are a way to trigger memories of what was read. I know there is more than one way to interpret things, but I tried imagining that Flavia represented the sweetness; as the youngest child she was at the bottom in pecking order. The "pie" could represent the whole family unit, or clues (pieces of pie) that make up the whole mystery.

I really liked the quote “Unless some sweetness at the bottom lie, who cares about the crinkle of the pie.”
The action certainly revolved around Flavia and without her insight there wouldn't be much to comment on concerning the mystery.

MEMBER LOGIN
Remember me
BECOME A MEMBER it's free

Now serving over 80,000 book clubs & ready to welcome yours. Join us and get the Top Book Club Picks of 2022 (so far).

SEARCH OUR READING GUIDES Search
Search




FEATURED EVENTS
PAST AUTHOR CHATS
JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...