Many members of our group were suprised how much we liked this tale. Some admited dreading reading it and were pleased they did. Most learned alot about Frank Llloyd Wright and while we agreed he was a remarkable architect he really did not know much about interpersonal relationships. All were suprised by what happened to the love of this life.

Ten of our twelve members voted. Some rated a 5 (top score) others 2.5 (low score). The group enjoyed a glimpse into a time period that occurred when we were growing up. NO one remembered hearing about the tight rope walker. We like most characters but felt the photographer of graffiti didn't fit in, didn't like the story line of the rich girl gone bad/artist character. Most other characters believable and author did a good job for the most part of intertwining the rest of the characters.

Those who read or completed the book thought that for a history book this read fairly well. Using partcular survivors from did towns was a good way for the story to unfold. One member stated she could partially taste the dust in her mouth while she read the book. Interesting insights into how man created the dust bowl. Seems to be a recurring theme in the world.

I am more of a fiction reader but I could not put this book down. I started it on the plane when traveling for work. I ended up staying up very late two nights in a row. First to get Louie out of the ocean and second out of the Prison of War camps. Riveting story. Also fascinating that after all the head trauma he did not suffer any longterm effects. Or at least he seems to not have any mental decline when relaying his harrowing tale. I suspect his bravado attitude and child pranks and ingenuity are what helped him survive. one of the best non fiction stories I've read.
It's also amazing that there are probably a thousand other harrowing stories out there that will never be told. What a tribute to all the veterans of war.

While it was interesting to find out about how spoiled a person Hemingway was and a good study of a maniac depressive person I found it rather boring. Other than being a good writer Hemingway had few redeeming qualities. Hadley got the good end of the deal when she divorced him.
I did find the bull fights interesting. When I was a girl we went to Mexico and watch a bull fight. Brought back some memories. I also checked the skiing place he went to and lived off of others. I couldn't understand what his parents did that was so wrong to turn him against them. They gave him the ability initially have a good education and provided for him.

Once again I enjoyed this authors style. in general if you like Kate Morton books you'll like this one. She cleverly weaves several stories into one.

Wow, cheers to Rudy! His debut novel ranks up there with Robin Cook, Tess Gerritsen, and James Rollins. What do you get when you mix venture capitalist with medical research/discovery? A very interesting tale.
Not to mention a topic that most people have a definite opinion, yet the author did a great job just presenting the story letting you make your own ethical decision.
The would be a great book to discuss at book club.