This is my favorite book by my favorite author. This is not your typical romance; this is an epic romance that demonstrates that true love is not a physical longing and fulfillment. Nor is it about unrequited feelings. Jayber's devotion to the one he loves is not the story of a nerd who can't get a girlfriend; it is the story of a man who recognizes the value of a particular woman and has no regrets about being faithful to her, though there is no sexual relationship. It is, too, the continuing story of a place, beautifully rendered; realistic and fully realized. Loss and joy are there; and, mostly, the extraordinary lives of ordinary people.

This is a case of fiction illuminating more acurately actual historical events than a tome of non-fiction could. The blend of past and present are skillfully handled, as is the blend of history with present relationships and a possible romance between two people who have an intense connection through historical events.

A unique perspective among the many crime novels available. It was puzzling to me why, though we know the outcome, the story is compelling and suspenseful.

Picoult always chooses interesting subject matter. I liked this, and think for groups it elicits many talking points. However, Picoult's actual writing is not impressive.