Member Profile

Name : Shan S.

My Reviews

Beautiful, Interesting, Inspiring

City of Girls: A Novel by Elizabeth Gilbert
Fun, Interesting, Adventurous

It’s ok. But I have some big issues with it which stopped me from liking it overall. Loved the first part. Young and careless in New York.
Then it just sort of fizzled out. And I was left disappointed. Just over half the book building up our interested and our love for the characters. And then we barely hear about any of them. It’s not until just less than a quarter left and we finally find out who Angela’s father is the and the reason for the whole tale. But my care factor about Frank Greco is zero!! I want to hear about Celia and Peg and Olive and Billy and Anthony and Edna and Roland and Benjamin and Mr Herbert......

I didn’t like Vivian. Got sick of hearing about her sexual exploits and how pretty she thought she was. She was actually quite a bore. I only tolerated her to hear about the other characters and then once they were out of the picture I didn’t really care about hearing more about bloody vivien.

And I now know that I really really really don’t like Elizabeth Gilbert. Hated eat prey love. Did not think much of her in a recent interview with Richard Fiedler and now this!!!
Big problem with the book....... how did she ever think this was reasonable as a letter to Angela??? It just doesn’t make sense. And would she have really needed to go into so much detail about herself to this person to explain a simple friendship? Makes me dislike the Vivian character even more. Totally self indulgent to think that someone’s daughter writing to ask about her father wants to actually hear her life story?? She would be wanting to learn more about her father .... not about Vivian?? It just doesn’t work.

Beautiful, Slow, Inspiring

Addictive, Poorly Written, Confusing

Adventurous, Interesting, Fun

Fun, Inspiring, Interesting

Insightful, Informative, Dramatic

One Winter Morning by Isabelle Broom

Isaac and the Egg by Palmer Bobby

Daisy Jones & The Six: A Novel by Reid Taylor Jenkins
Interesting, Fun, Addictive

The Dickens Boy by Thomas Keneally

Anxious People: A Novel by Backman Fredrik
Fun, Interesting, Insightful

Insightful, Adventurous, Inspiring

The Yield: A Novel by Winch Tara June

Becoming by Michelle Obama
Interesting, Inspiring, Beautiful

Such a Fun Age by Kiley Reid
Insightful, Dramatic, Fun

Inspiring, Adventurous, Informative

CIRCE by Madeline Miller
Adventurous, Interesting, Epic

Insightful, Dramatic, Interesting

Inspiring, Interesting, Informative

Addictive, Dramatic, Beautiful

Interesting, Fun, Insightful

Beartown: A Novel by Backman Fredrik
Interesting, Adventurous, Inspiring

Beautiful, Insightful, Dramatic

Tom Lake: A Novel by Ann Patchett
Beautiful, Slow, Insightful


It Ends with Us: A Novel by Colleen Hoover
Addictive, Romantic, Dramatic

Remember me

Now serving over 80,000 book clubs & ready to welcome yours. Join us and get the Top Book Club Picks of 2022 (so far).


Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...