BKMT READING GUIDES



 
Inspiring,
Beautiful,
Insightful

5 reviews

Eating Heaven
by Jennie Shortridge

Published: 2005-09-06
Paperback : 304 pages
168 members reading this now
34 clubs reading this now
29 members have read this book
Recommended to book clubs by 5 of 5 members

Nothing gets Eleanor Samuels's heart racing like a double scoop of mocha fudge chunk. Sure, the magazine writer may have some issues aside from food, but she isn't quite ready to face them. Then her beloved Uncle Benny falls ill, and what at first seems scary and daunting becomes a ...

No other editions available.
Add to Club Selections
Add to Possible Club Selections
Add to My Personal Queue
Jump to

Introduction

Nothing gets Eleanor Samuels's heart racing like a double scoop of mocha fudge chunk. Sure, the magazine writer may have some issues aside from food, but she isn't quite ready to face them. Then her beloved Uncle Benny falls ill, and what at first seems scary and daunting becomes a blessing in disguise. Because while she cooks and cares for him-and enjoys a delicious flirtation with a new chef in town-Eleanor begins to uncover some long-buried secrets about her emotionally frayed family and may finally get the chance to become the woman she's always wanted to be.

Editorial Review

No editorial review at this time.

Excerpt

Tonight Why not Eat Light?

7 Super-Easy suppers that won't weigh you down!

by Eleanor Samuels

You've picked up little Susie from soccer practice and Tommy's on his way home from the swim meet. Your husband dashes in clutching his briefcase and gym back after his post-work spin class. The last thing you want to do is load up your active family with unwanted fat and calories. How can you make a quick, easy dinner that's also healthy?

Yes, that is the burning question, isn't it? Not "How can we end world hunger?" or "What exactly is in fat-free cheese?" Not "What on earth is this woman doing cooking for everyone else while they're out doing something for themselves?"

More to the point, what am I doing writing crap like this?

-------------------------------------------------------

Chapter 1

Cheese. Bread. Butter. Noodles. You can almost hear America screaming, “Fat! Carbs! Fat! Carbs!” and it’s my job to calm the masses, to lead them down the “lite” path. Sure, writing for the kinds of magazines I do won’t fetch me any journalism prizes, but if nothing else, it’s easy. I start with a perfectly wonderful recipe and subtract and substitute everything good until it tastes like a rough imitation of its former self. Then I think of the most insipid, alliterative title I can, incorporating the tried-and-true “Magic Number”—that tantalizing digit that promises the impossible:

5 Fantastic Low-fat French Fry Recipes

6 Sexy New Desserts That Will Help You Stay in Shape!

7 Stupendous Suppers to Make Everyone Love You and Achieve World Peace

If I could write anything I wanted to, I’d write about the splendor of butter and sugar hitting your taste buds at the same time, or smooth pasta and sharp Romano, a fat strawberry dipped in bittersweet chocolate. That kind of nirvana can only be achieved through fat and calories, and, yes, carbohydrates. Eat, for God’s sake, I’d tell the food phobes, the Atkins addicts, the warily weight watching. They’ve made consuming food far too complicated.

Here’s the article I should write:

How to Eat: Six Sure-Fire Techniques to Get Food Into Your Mouth

1. Place food on fork

2. Insert fork in mouth

3. Slide fork out, leaving food on tongue

4. Chew (food, not tongue)

5. Enjoy!

6. Repeat

I wish getting food into Uncle Benny’s mouth was that easy.

“What’d you say this stuff was?” he asks, sitting at his kitchen table in the same chair he’s always sat in, as long as I’ve known him. He stabs a piece of tofu with his fork, brings it close to his face to inspect it. “Mongoose and peanuts?”

“Very funny,” I say.

He’s fighting a flu-bug so he’s wearing the green robe that’s seen better days and tube socks, drugstore reading glasses parked on top of his not-quite-convincing comb-over. Thai tofu with broccolini and peanuts is probably a stretch for a meat and potatoes kind of guy, but I had a batch left over from my last article: “Why Order In? 8 Asian Dishes With Half the Fat.”

He sniffs the tofu, wrinkles his nose for effect.

I sigh, feigning irritation. It’s a dance we do, Uncle Benny and I, an old soft-shoe. He almost always likes what I bring him.

“For God’s sake. Just taste it, you old fart.”

A hint of a smile sneaks across his grizzled mug and he winks, then slides the fork into his mouth. He closes his eyes and smiles for real, face crumpling in that papery way I’ve loved since I was six years old.

“See? You gotta trust me, Ben. Cooking is the one thing I know how to do.”

Uncle Benny, on the other hand, knows how to do almost everything: he can unstick a door, quiet the squeaking of car brakes, and banish the burning rubber smell that wafts from my Kitchen Aid mixer when I use it too much. He means more to me than my own father did, but the truth is, he’s not my uncle. I only wish he were.

“Why do we call him uncle?” Christine asked once when we were eating our allotted two Oreos in the kitchen after school.

“Because we can’t call him dad,” I said, and our older sister Anne looked up from her math book and widened her eyes, stifling a snicker. She’d started junior high and was rapidly developing a superior attitude along with breasts.

Mom turned from the sink, face stricken, and walked two steps toward me. She raised her delicate hand, dripping with dishwater, and slapped me. She’d never hit anyone, as far as I knew, but I wasn’t surprised. At the age of eleven, I’d recently changed my formerly reverential opinion of her and it was almost as though I wanted her to slap me.

“Mom!” Christine cried. “Why’d you do that?”

She didn’t answer, just glared at me. I returned her stare until her eyes began to soften and fill, and she turned back to the dishes. Anne slunk down behind her book. Christine looked at me, nine-year-old eyes welling. “Why’d she do that?” she asked again.

I shrugged. I wanted to touch the hot wet swath of skin on my face, to cool it against my glass of milk. To feel where she’d laid her hand on me, if only in anger, but I wouldn’t in front of her. I grabbed the Oreo package and headed for my room, knowing my mother would be horrified at my brazenness. When I’d finished eating every cookie, I tilted the package and slid the crumbs into my mouth, then licked the blobs of white filling from the cellophane. Feeling sick to my stomach, I reclined on the bed, holding the side of my face, annoyed that it no longer hurt.

After I’ve cleared the dinner dishes, Uncle Benny breaks out the cards for a game of gin rummy. I watch his hands as he deals the cards: yellowed nails, fingers bent, skin spotted and sallow. Hands aged beyond their years by twisting greasy bolts, scraping knuckles on engine blocks. He never complains about the arthritis, but it’s painful to look at. I pick up my cards and say, “Nice hand, Ben. Maybe for once I’ll beat you.”

The kitchen’s sunshine yellow was Aunt Yolanda’s idea shortly after they married, an antidote to the gloom of Portland’s long rainy winters. The metal stool I sit on now was here before she was, paint-spattered and worn, and, like me, it’s now outlasted her. Even though they had a long and, we thought, happy marriage, Yolanda left Benny last year with no explanation. A page of secrets ripped from a diary.

My sisters and I speculate: midlife crisis? She’s still in her fifties, even though Benny’s on the downhill slide to seventy. A younger man, maybe, closer to her own age? “A woman?” I say for effect, knowing it will get a rise out of stodgy Anne, a gasp from Christine. What we don’t mention, of course, is Mom, but it seems impossible after all these years. I certainly can’t ask Benny why Yolanda left. He mists over at the slightest reminder of her: her name on a piece of junk mail, a pink emery board discovered between couch cushions.

When Benny’s beaten me soundly three games in a row, he pulls the cards into a pile and rests his hands upon them.

“You look tired,” I say, and he nods. It’s not quite eight o’clock.

At the door, he helps me with my raincoat. “Thanks for the dinner, honey. You should be feeding some young fella, not your old fart uncle.”

I snort. Young fella. Benny will forever think of me as a kid. “Yeah, well, when he shows up, I’ll let you know.” I swing my purse onto my shoulder, patting my pockets for keys.

He squeezes my arm. “Believe I’ll just watch TV until bed,” he says, then shuffles toward the couch, settling slowly into the cushions, clutching his abdomen. His face is too serious, his movements too careful.

“What’s wrong? I didn't poison you, did I?” Maybe tofu wasn’t such a good idea.

He waves a hand at me as he rolls onto his side. “Nah, I’m fine, Ellie. Just can’t seem to shake this goddamn flu. It ups and hits me every so often.”

I walk over and pull the throw from the back of the sofa, spread it over his scrawny legs. I’m tempted to tuck him in, but I just stand and look at him, wondering now if I should leave.

“What’re you gawking at? Go home, Miss Roosevelt. I’m fine.”

“You’re sure?”

He raises his eyebrows, an empty threat.

“Have you been going to the tanning parlor?” I tilt my head, look closely at his face. It’s been bugging me all night, and I just figured it out. The color of his skin looks artificial and tawny. Who knows—maybe he’s thinking about dating again.

He guffaws, inspecting his arms in the dim lamplight. “What the hell are you talking about?” he says, shaking his head, and he looks like himself again, just sleepy and getting older. He grabs the remote from the coffee table and clicks on the TV. “Now if you don’t mind, Matlock comes on at eight.”

He’s fine, I decide. I resist the urge to lean down and kiss his cheek, something we reserve for only the best or worst of occasions.

“Okay, okay,” I say, walking back toward the door, digging through the lists and receipts and wayward mints in the bottom of my purse until I hear the jangle of keys. “I’ll be back Thursday, and I promise I’ll bring you something with meat in it this time. But you have to promise me you’ll call the doctor tomorrow, okay?”

There’s no answer and I turn to look at him. He’s already asleep, jaw drooping, hand hanging idly off the couch, remote dropped to the floor. I hold my breath and count—one, two, three, four, five—until he begins to snore. Then I turn out the lights, click the lock into place, and step out into the cool March night. view abbreviated excerpt only...

Discussion Questions

No discussion questions at this time.

Notes From the Author to the Bookclub

Discussion Questions from the Author:

1. The characters in this novel are struggling to learn how to properly care for one another on many different levels. In what ways do they succeed or fail to be nurturing?

2. How does Eleanor’s attitude toward food change throughout the book? What does her inability to vomit signify in her life? Her decrease in appetite?

3. The author does not reveal Eleanor’s actual size. Why do you think she made this decision, and how do you feel about it? What do you imagine Eleanor’s size to be, and how does it differ from or match your group members’ perceptions?

4. Food is described so intimately and beautifully in Eating Heaven, it is almost a character itself. How does the author use food to tell the story? Find passages where food reveals emotions, desires, connections, or conflicts.

5. What spurs Eleanor to see Suzanne Long, the food therapist? Why does she stop seeing her? What does Eleanor learn from Suzanne, and what does she learn on her own?

6. Why does Bebe refuse to see Benny, even when he is dying?

7. What is Bebe referring to when she tells Eleanor on page 199, ‘Benny isn’t quite the angel you think he is?’ How did your perceptions of Bebe and of her relationship with Benny change over the course of the story?

8. What would you do, if you found out that your family had a secret they had kept from you all your life?

9. Eleanor eats when she is stressed or upset. How do Anne and Christine cope with their life-changing problems?

10. What, for Benny, is the most difficult part of his illness?

11. Think about the men in Eleanor’s life—Benny, Stefan, Henry, and the memory of her father. How are these relationships similar? Different? What issues, if any, does she resolve with them by the end of the book, and how?

Book Club Recommendations

I served fruit pizza and a sweet moscato wine.
by cindyb (see profile) 06/26/09
I thought it would be nice to serve something fairly healthy considering the topic of the book!

Member Reviews

Overall rating:
 
 
  "A Joy to Read"by Kris C. (see profile) 11/17/11

A dramatic story about everyday life and the struggles of caring for someone who is dying. A touching story about families, sisters and relationships with a little fun thrown in from food and its role... (read more)

 
  "Made me hungry for more...."by Johnna H. (see profile) 07/01/09

I love books that go back and forth from present to past to fill you in on important details or backstory. Jennie Shortridge does that here beautifully!

Eleanor Samuels lives in her rent

... (read more)

 
  "Eating Heaven"by Cara R. (see profile) 06/30/09

I really enjoyed this book even though it did take me the first 30-50 pages to really get into it. At first the main character comes off as a bit negative, but then the real story/plot begins and it is... (read more)

 
  "A very moving book!"by Cindy B. (see profile) 06/26/09

I couldn't put it down. It started a little slow but as you get into the book you begin to relate to the characters. There were parts that made me cry!

 
  "Keeps you waiting"by Heather M. (see profile) 07/31/08

The book really keeps you waiting, but does not give you the answers you are looking for. It was ok and I have loaned my book to a friend, but I would rate it a 6 out of 10!

 
  "A woman with hidden family secrets and who is stuck in a rut."by Courtney F. (see profile) 07/28/08

I liked the book, I liked that there were not a lot of characters to keep track of. A very easy read.

 
  "Fun, touching and eloquent"by Aleksandra E. (see profile) 06/04/08

This book was surprising in the fact that it grips you right from the start & you are capitivated until the very end. It was well written, insightful and sweet. It has subtle twists and turns and I was... (read more)

 
  "Family dysfunction and death"by Marion B. (see profile) 12/10/07

I very much enjoyed the story itself and wanted more details about each of the characters. I thought each character could use more rounding. Just my opinion though-

 
  "Woman looks to find herself through food and a past she does not understand, but becomes pleasently surprised when a loved one's illness and possible death comes knocking at her door."by Marlo M. (see profile) 11/02/07

This was a pleasant, quick read. I felt like I knew Eleanor instantly and could relate to her life quirks. I wanted more from her romance with a local chef, but maybe there will be a part I... (read more)

 
  "Easy read that keeps you interested"by Maria L. (see profile) 10/09/07

OVerall a good read that makes for fun discussion

Rate this book
MEMBER LOGIN
Remember me
BECOME A MEMBER it's free

Now serving over 80,000 book clubs & ready to welcome yours. Join us and get the Top Book Club Picks of 2022 (so far).

SEARCH OUR READING GUIDES Search
Search




FEATURED EVENTS
PAST AUTHOR CHATS
JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...