BKMT READING GUIDES

The Appearance of Annie van Sinderen
by Katherine Howe

Published: 2015-09-15
Hardcover : 400 pages
6 members reading this now
2 clubs reading this now
1 member has read this book
A haunting, contemporary love story from the New York Times bestselling author of Conversion


It’s July in New York City, and aspiring filmmaker Wes Auckerman has just arrived to start his summer term at NYU. While shooting a séance at a psychic’s in the East Village, he meets a ...
No other editions available.
Add to Club Selections
Add to Possible Club Selections
Add to My Personal Queue
Jump to

Introduction

A haunting, contemporary love story from the New York Times bestselling author of Conversion


It’s July in New York City, and aspiring filmmaker Wes Auckerman has just arrived to start his summer term at NYU. While shooting a séance at a psychic’s in the East Village, he meets a mysterious, intoxicatingly beautiful girl named Annie.

As they start spending time together, Wes finds himself falling for her, drawn to her rose-petal lips and her entrancing glow. There’s just something about her that he can’t put his finger on, something faraway and otherworldly that compels him to fall even deeper. Annie’s from the city, and yet she seems just as out of place as Wes feels. Lost in the chaos of the busy city streets, she’s been searching for something—a missing ring. And now Annie is running out of time and needs Wes’s help. As they search together, Annie and Wes uncover secrets lurking around every corner, secrets that will reveal the truth of Annie’s dark past.

Editorial Review

No editorial review at this time.

Excerpt

The morning light is streaming into the first floor hallway, pouring like rays of heaven through the transom window over the front door, glinting off the hallstand mirror. I squint against it, and descend another step. Usually the morning light is soft, orange and muted, since more buildings have gone up on this block. But today the light is harsh and white.

I bring my hand up to shade my eyes, peering into the glare.

The whiteness is so bright it’s almost a haze, or a cloud. It fills the hall, lightening the dove-gray walls and swallowing the floorboards into invisibility.

I descend another couple of steps, and the light glows so bright that I can’t see where I’m stepping. My feet hunt about for each stair tread, and I grope for the bannister to steady myself, but I can’t find it. My hand plunges into space, grasping nothing.

Finally my foot lands hard on the floor, and the carpet runner is missing, and my foot makes an unfamiliar sound in the front hallway. Voices are all around me. Their murmurs rise and fall, like music, or like the crowds of people outside the African Grove Theater on Bleeker, a clamor of voices and sounds and smells and everyone talking at once, but somehow never to each other. I can’t make any of them out, and none of them seem to be talking to me, but they buzz around to my ears like bees, close enough that I struggle to bat them away.

“Papa?” I call out.

The brightness of the morning sun is making my eyes ache.

“Order up!” someone shouts close to my ear, making me jump from surprise.

“What?” I say, looking left and right.

I can’t see anyone. I’m alone, but somehow I’m surrounded by people and smells and I can hear a bell jangling, but I can’t tell if it’s the bell Mother uses to summon us for meals or if it’s something different.

“Mother?” I try this time, wondering if she’s serving breakfast in the drawing room for some reason. Perhaps she has guests? But she wouldn’t entertain at breakfast. And she would have made sure Beattie and I dressed up.

A whiff of air brushes past my cheeks, and I spin where I’m standing, but all I see is the vaguest outline of the front hallway filled with pure white light.

I move nearer to the drawing room, reaching a hand forward to where the sliding door should be, but my hand keeps going forward in space, deeper into a void, not meeting anything.

“Keep it moving, keep it moving! Whatchou want, huh?” someone barks on my left.

My eyes wide with terror, I spin again, hunting for the speaker.

“Who said that?” I raise my voice. “I can hear you!”

Nobody answers me, but still I hear the voices, talking amongst themselves, little snippets of conversation that I can almost understand, but not quite.

Another whiff of air brushes past my other cheek, and I close my eyes, feeling whatever it is pass through me as though it were a summer breeze.

“What is this?” I ask myself. “What is this?”

When I open my eyes again, I’m standing in the middle of the drawing room, but it’s not the drawing room. It’s overlit with glaring white lights that hum overhead. Most confusingly of all, it’s packed to the gills with total strangers.

They’re gathered around small tables I’ve never seen before. All Mother’s carefully chosen fixtures are gone, the horsehair sofas and the occasional chairs and the hulking marble mantelpiece with the gilt-framed mirror. Or rather, there’s a mirror where the gilt-framed one used to be, but it’s spotted and chipped, and someone has written on it, what looks like a long list, with words that don’t make any sense to me. Like Latin, but not Latin.

Calzone. Pepperoni. Mortadella.

The gas chandelier is gone, and instead it’s as though the whole ceiling is lit from within by white light that flickers, but not the way a candle flickers. The smell of food is mouthwatering.

But who are all these people?

I stare at them, and none of them pay any attention to me. They’re all different ages, dressed in the most bizarre way. Some of them look like they aren’t even dressed at all. Girls in black camisoles lean over tables, their bodies loose, their hair flowing down their backs. They’re with boys, most of them, and they’re all eating with their hands. It’s like a savory kind of pie, only without a crust. Like a half-pie, half quiche. They all act like it’s completely normal that they’re there, eating breakfast in my mother’s drawing room.

Panicking, I grip my skirts in my fists.

Where did these people come from? Who said they could be in our house?

“Who ARE YOU?” I scream.

Nobody answers me!

“Tell me who you ARE!” I bellow, rushing up to one of the tables.

There’s a girl sitting there, one of the ones who’s left the house in her nightdress as far as I can tell, and she’s bending forward and laughing, and I can see all the way down her bodice. She’s completely unlaced, and if Mother knew this prostitute was in her drawing room, I don’t know what she’d do. She’d call Papa, and she’d call Winston, and if they didn’t come she’d beat the girl senseless with a fireplace poker herself.

“You can’t be here!” I shout in her ear.

The girl just keeps laughing and talking, chewing with her mouth open.

I put my hands on the table between them, leaning into their conversation. The boy is just as bad. He reeks like a French waterfront whore, and his hair is so short it looks like he’s been lately shaved for lice. Neither of them takes the slightest notice of me.

“Get out of my HOUSE!” I scream at the top of my lungs, and I take hold of the table where they’re sitting, grab it with both my hands and make ready to hurl it away, crashing it across the room in a righteous fury.

“Annatje?” someone says softly.

I look up, my eyes crazed with violence.

Mother is standing by the sliding door of the drawing room, her hand resting on the burled walnut that she chose for the wainscoting. She is giving me a curious look.

Panting, I look down at my hands, and find that they are resting on the card table that Mother left out from Papa’s whist game last week. No one has been in the drawing room since then. There’s a round stain where one of the Corporation men left his sherry glass without a coaster. It looks dried and gray in the morning light.

“Is everything all right?” she asks me lightly.

I release the edge of the card table and smooth my hands down the front of my day dress.

“Of course, Mother,” I say with some difficulty.

“I thought I hard you shout, just now.”

I level my eyes at my mother’s face and smile prettily at her.

“Shout?” I echo, as mildly as I can.

“Yes. I thought I heard you raise your voice, a moment ago.”

It’s not like Mother to press the issue. Usually we maintain a tacit agreement that we will each pretend I do what I’m supposed to do, virtually all of the time. It’s easier on both of us.

“I’m so sorry, Mother,” I say. “Perhaps you heard someone out in the street? A peddler? They’re getting louder and louder, aren’t they?”

She watches me for a long moment.

“Indeed they are,” she says after a time. “Jews,” she adds under her breath.

We stare at each other across the length of the drawing room, each wondering who is going to call me on my bluff.

At length she says “Well. Beatrice is down. We’re about to eat.”

“All right,” I say.

She’s on the point of leaving, when she gives me a last long look and says “Are you quite sure you’re all right, Annie?”

Her unaccustomed use of my preferred name takes me aback, and I have to steady myself on the card table.

“I… I think so,” I say.

What I want to do is run to her, and have her hold me and tell me that I’m just having a bad dream within a bad dream. I want her to tell me that it’s probably on account of my having too much Madeira, which I shouldn’t have accepted from Mrs. Dudley at the Corporation dinner, and it serves me right for indulging too much, and it’s just this sort of thing that’s made her consider joining the Temperance Society, except that Papa wouldn’t allow it until after the Canal were open, for political reasons. I want to tell her that my cameo’s missing, and beg her to help me find it, and I want to tell her that it was Herschel who gave it to me, and why.

“I think… perhaps, there’s something the matter with my head.” I finish.

I bring my hand to my temple.

“The Madeira,” my mother sniffs, and in a way, her assumption fills me with relief, as it is exactly what Mother would say, if we were really having this conversation. “It serves you right, I think. In any case, there’s coffee on the breakfast table.”

She whisks away down the hall, and I can hear the rustling of her skirts as she goes.

I lean myself ever so slightly to the left, so that I can see further down the hall, and confirm that she’s really gone.

And then I grab up my skirts and run for the front door. view abbreviated excerpt only...

Discussion Questions

A) THE APPEARANCE OF ANNIE VAN SINDEREN has a lot to say about image, representation, and memory, both for individuals and for haunted spaces. Have you ever been to New York City? Did you already have an imaginary image of what it would be like? How was the reality of the lived experience different from the imagined version? Was any of it the same?

B) Wes and Annie develop feelings for each other even though their relationship is impossible, divided as they are by relations with other people, by time, by space, and by experience. Have you ever experienced impossible love? Is it worth it, even when you know it can never work?

C) Have you ever seen a ghost?

D) How did you know?

Notes From the Author to the Bookclub

A Conversation with Katherine Howe

Author of THE APPEARANCE OF ANNIE VAN SINDEREN

Q: THE APPEARANCE OF ANNIE VAN SINDEREN is set in NYC, both present day and with glimpses at 1825. Why did you choose this region of the country to tell this story?

A: New York City is a figure of myth and magic for many people, and I am no exception. I went to college in New York, and so it’s the place where I went to try to figure out who I wanted to be. I think New York has served that role from its inception. New York is a city of new arrivals, and of people passing through. I like to imagine that the city carries traces of all the people who were drawn there, or forced to go there, or dreamed of going there. And I’m not the only one – the Hudson River valley has been rich in ghost lore, almost from the very beginning. Ghosts can be both frightening and reassuring – they both represent our fear of the unknown, while also reassuring us that others have gone before us. In ANNIE VAN I wanted to imagine what would happen if a remnant of New York’s past were suddenly confronted with New York’s present.

Q: This novel masterfully blends the historical with the supernatural and does so in a contemporary setting. What draws you to this kind of story?

A: Thank you! I love thinking about all the different layers of time that overlap over a given place. Some spaces, like old New England towns, let you see those layers. But other places – like New York City – prefer to keep their layers secret. I like to imagine what it would be like if we could draw the curtain of the present back just long enough to get a glimpse of what was there before. Also, our understanding of how the world works changes according to our historical moment. What one time considers supernatural another time considers real. Fiction is a wonderful way of exploring different mindsets.

Q: What were some of the more surprising things you learned while researching this book?

A: It’s always a shock to realize how quickly New York grew in the nineteenth century. There was a time when the intersection of First and Bowery was the far northern reaches of the city. I also got to learn a lot about the opening of the Erie Canal in 1825, which totally changed New York and much of the western expansion of the United States. When the canal was finished they fired a cannonade the full length of the waterway, from Buffalo all the way to Manhattan. It must have been spectacular, when it happened. I discovered that Seneca Village was a completely self-contained community of free black people and Irish immigrants when it was flattened under Central Park near what is now the Upper West Side. And I was really surprised to learn how long New York has been saturated with ghost stories. We’re a young country, and yet we’re stalked by our past whether we know it or not.

Q: Are any of the characters inspired by real-life people? If so, how did you discover them?

A: For the most part, the characters are all fictional. Annie gets her first name from a story about a servant named Anna Dorothea Swarts who was dragged to death after being tied to a horse by her master in the 1760s. By the 1820s she had morphed into a well-known ghost legend, of a woman dragged by her hair screaming behind a horse. That evolution illustrates one of the ways that history and folklore can become intertwined. Her last name was picked from the Social Register, because it was Dutch and because it brings to mind “cinders,” a play on words that Maddie uses in her graffiti art. The other characters – Wes, Tyler, Maddie, Eastlin, Herschel – are all figures of my imagination. But the interior of Wes and Eastlin’s shared dorm room is completely based on my own New York City freshman year dorm. Cinderblocks!

Q: The book is full of film references as Wes is an aspiring filmmaker at NYU. Are the films of particular significance to you? Why was it important to incorporate them into the story?

A: Most of us have never been to New York City, and yet all of us feel as though we know New York City because we experience it on film. I was really interested in the idea that a city can be haunted by these different versions of itself, portrayed and preserved in media. In a funny way we’re doing the same thing as individual people, creating these social media versions of ourselves that are related to, yet not identical to, our “real” selves. I also wanted to think about how media and memory intersect, or overwrite each other. Finally, I liked the idea of creating a character who goes from being a watcher to being a doer. Wes begins the story not entirely sure of who he is, and he copes with that uncertainty by filming other people. In many respects ANNIE VAN is a coming of age story about how to learn to fashion the people we want to be.

Q: Art plays an important role in all of your fiction. Can you speak a bit about the art that appears in this book and its significance?

A: I started my professional life as an art historian, and so I’ve found that details of artwork and material culture feature large in my fictional imagination. Art is one language for communicating ideas, and portraiture can be particularly compelling because it illustrates how individual people want themselves to be seen. Seeing and not seeing, or seeing and not understanding what is seen, are big themes in ANNIE VAN SINDEREN. At a certain moment in the story the kids look at a family portrait of Annie and her parents, and learn an important clue. But in addition to the clue they also learn how Annie’s parents thought of themselves, and what kind of message about themselves they wanted to send. The cameo that Herschel gives Annie serves as an important link across time and space. Many of us imbue everyday objects with special meaning and significance, and that’s true for my characters too.

Q: What’s next for you?

A: I’m hard at work on a new novel, which will be set in the world of pirates and corsairs on an obscure island in the Gulf of Mexico in the 1810s. The novel will explore the fictional story of the real-life mistress of Jean Laffite, an infamous French smuggler who fled New Orleans after the War of 1812 and set up an illegal pirate enclave on Galveston. They faced Karankawa attacks, a hurricane, and the US Navy, and the island has been dogged by rumors of buried treasure ever since. There’s going to be some magic too.Curious readers can watch me brainstorm here: https://www.pinterest.com/katherinebhowe/galvez-grand/

Book Club Recommendations

Member Reviews

Overall rating:
 
There are no user reviews at this time.
Rate this book
MEMBER LOGIN
Remember me
BECOME A MEMBER it's free

Now serving over 80,000 book clubs & ready to welcome yours. Join us and get the Top Book Club Picks of 2022 (so far).

SEARCH OUR READING GUIDES Search
Search




FEATURED EVENTS
PAST AUTHOR CHATS
JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...