The Secret Papers of Madame Olivetti
by Annie Vanderbilt
Paperback- $14.27

The coast of Southern France sparkles in this sexy, mature, and engaging debut novel. Lily has come to southern France in search of a new ...

Overall rating:

 

How would you rate this book?

Member ratings

 
  "Two thumbs down" by labiblica (see profile) 01/15/09

Not for serious readers. Chick lit only.

 
  "Lily Crisp is a one-dimensional character whose focus is solely on satisfying her own sexual needs/desires." by mimiz (see profile) 01/15/09

 
  "Lily (the main character) writes her memoirs on a typewriter that becomes another character." by npfiacco (see profile) 01/15/09

The book is a quick, light, at times fun, fluff/fuzzy piece of writing. Lily is an underdeveloped character who starts out as a self-absorbed young girl and does not grow, change, or mature through her experiences/memoirs. She isn't a particularly good mother, wife, sister, daughter, or friend. There are several long, meaningless passages of "over-the-top" descriptions that drag on the story line. If the author had written the novel in a shorter time span, this reader feels the story would have been more clear, more focused, and more concise/tight. As it was, the reader could not truly identify with the main characters or care about them and what happened to them, as they were more charactures instead of real people. The story rambled, moved in strange, illogical ways, and had too many unnecessary, non-developed characters. The ending seemed a bit too contrived.

There are, however, some things to enjoy about the novel. The premise of a 50 something woman spending a month alone with a typewriter in a cottage on the coast of France could certainly appeal to many readers. Also, readers could probably transport themselves with the descriptions of place (Idaho, Wisconsin, cottage in France). The scene of Lily burning the papers in the fireplace is well done. The idea of the typewriter becoming a character is unique and interesting; however, the cat (and the writer's explanation at the back of the book) is a stretch, at best. Other than criticisms of the writing, and maybe a fantasy or two, my book group didn't find much to discuss in the book and would not recommend it to another group.

 
  "Enjoyed the description of France, Wisconsin and Idaho. A fast read" by april35 (see profile) 01/16/09

A fast read. Lily seemed to be very self absorbed.She and alonso seemed a lot alike in many ways. It was interesting how the author used the typewriter almost like a charater and named the book.

 
  "Lily lacks depth!" by ShanaM (see profile) 02/04/09

Although our book club had a good discussion about this book I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
I found Lily's character under developed and lacking depth. She is a self-absorbed, needy woman who seems disinterested in her children, unhappy in her marriage and as far as her travels are concerned she seems to be looking for what she evidently finds missing in her personal life.
Thankfully I did not buy this book!

 
  "An American in the South of France looking back over her life" by GigiMc (see profile) 03/18/09

I won this book for our book club. We hadn't read it yet, but I did and I DO NOT recommend that we read it. It was silly and boring and I was really surprised to get a book like this from this website! Usually the books recommended here are very good. This was like a bad romance novel. I was very disappointed.

 
  "Predictable" by barbaraross (see profile) 05/22/11

ok, fine for the beach. there was no star between 2 and 3 on the above choices. I would have given it a 2.5.

MEMBER LOGIN
Remember me
BECOME A MEMBER it's free

Now serving over 80,000 book clubs & ready to welcome yours. Join us and get the Top Book Club Picks of 2022 (so far).

SEARCH OUR READING GUIDES Search
Search




FEATURED EVENTS
PAST AUTHOR CHATS
JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...