BKMT READING GUIDES

Lessons in French: A Novel
by Hilary Reyl

Published: 2014-07-29
Paperback : 368 pages
1 member reading this now
0 club reading this now
1 member has read this book
An evocative, coming-of-age story about a Yale graduate’s year in Paris as an assistant to a legendary American photographer: “An appealing debut novel” (Oprah.com, Editor’s Pick).

It’s 1989, the Berlin Wall is coming down, and Kate has just graduated from Yale, eager to pursue ...
No other editions available.
Add to Club Selections
Add to Possible Club Selections
Add to My Personal Queue
Jump to

Introduction

An evocative, coming-of-age story about a Yale graduate’s year in Paris as an assistant to a legendary American photographer: “An appealing debut novel” (Oprah.com, Editor’s Pick).

It’s 1989, the Berlin Wall is coming down, and Kate has just graduated from Yale, eager to pursue her dreams as a fledgling painter. When she is offered a job as the assistant to Lydia Schell, a famous American photographer in Paris, she immediately accepts. It’s a chance not only to be at the center of the art world, but to return to France for the first time since, as a lonely nine-year-old girl, she was sent to the outskirts of Paris to live with cousins while her father was dying.

Kate may speak fluent French, but she arrives at the Schell household in the fashionable Sixth Arrondissement both overwhelmed and naïve. She finds herself surrounded by a seductive cast of characters: the members of the bright, pretentious family with whom she boards, their assortment of famous friends, Kate’s own flamboyant cousin, a fellow Yalie who seems to have it all figured out, and a bande of independently wealthy young men with royal lineage. As Kate rediscovers Paris and her roots there, she begins to question the kindness of the glamorous people to whom she is so drawn as well as her own motives in wanting their affection.

In compelling and sympathetic prose, Hilary Reyl perfectly captures this portrait of a precocious, ambitious young woman struggling to define herself in a vibrant world that spirals out of her control. Lessons in French is “rich and magnetic, a snapshot of one young woman’s life in a city at once ancient and bubbling over with life” (Booklist).

Editorial Review

Guest Review of â??Lesson in Frenchâ??

By Paula McLain

Paula McLainHilary Reyl

Can you ever have enough Paris? Obviously not, and though Hilary Reylâ??s engaging Lessons in French is set in 1989, nearly seventy years after Ernest and Hadley Hemingway caroused with their Bohemian set, Reylâ??s layered, sumptuous and spot-on details had me ready to buy a ticket to her Paris from page one.

In many ways, Kate is any young woman trying to figure out who she is amid the push and pull of others, but her new assistantship with the wildly glamorous and neurotic photographer, Lydia Schell, adds considerable torque in both directions. So does Lydiaâ??s impossibly dysfunctional family.

Granted, the trappings are deliciousâ??a chambre de bonne in the chic sixth arrondissement, promised elbow rubbing with Umberto Eco and Salman Rushdie, and the satisfaction of being indispensable to Lydia and her loved ones. The reality is so much more draining and dicey. Nearly all of her pittance of a salary pays her rent, and Lydia expects not just the work Katie was hired to do, but dog walking, schlepping out for spring rolls and strange diet pillsâ??oh, and blind gratitude and unquestioning loyalty to boot. But Lydiaâ??s a genius, right, doing socially important work? And who is Katie to stand up to her?

Who is Katie becomes the question of the book, and the thing that keeps us turning pages. Her principal gift, she tells us early on, is to reflect others back beautifully, and we see that emotional mirroring over and over in her. In trying to please everyone, to be endlessly diplomatic and necessary and reliable, Kate gets blurrier and more disoriented. In completing others, she loses herselfâ??and what will that malleability cost her, in the end?

I found Kate absolutely believable and familiar as a character (I know that girl, havenâ??t we all been that girl?) and thatâ??coupled with the sublime settingâ??was a winning combination for me. Paris isnâ??t mere seasoning in this debut novel, but a seven-course meal.

Like her heroine, Hilary Reyl spent considerable time in the City of Light, and one has the feeling that the book is a labor of love for the author, a way of paying homage to what she herself gained and lost in Paris, and to immortalize that experience in story. This is a wonderful first novel. Savor it with crème-filled croissants and peach kir, and prepare to be transported.

Excerpt

Chapter One

They say I have no accent and that this is a gift. Sometimes, people can detect a lilt in my voice, which makes them wonder which rural part of France I come from, or maybe which Scandinavian country. But no one can hear that I'm American. And yet, because I am not French, I show almost no signs of belonging to any group or class. In Paris, I am virtually transparent. A gift, perhaps. Un don, so to speak, voilà. But, when you feel invisible, there is no end to the trouble you can get into. ... view entire excerpt...

Discussion Questions

1. At the beginning of the Lessons In French, Kate explains her immature perception of art: “I was too literal. I loved the Monets, but I didn’t actually trust them” (p. 15). In what ways do you think her literal approach to her own art evolves as her year in Paris progresses? Does she finally develop a style? Can you recall a similar evolution in your own life?

2. Did the city of Paris come alive for you in the novel? If you have been there, did it evoke memories? If not, could you picture it? Was the sense of place an important aspect for you in your reading?

3. Because Lessons in French is set in 1989-90, before the advent of cell phones and social media, Kate is truly immersed in her experience of Paris and the Schell household. Although she can write and receive letters and make the occasional expensive phone call, she has none of the instant connectedness that travelers have today. How do you think this affects her experience? How has technology affected your own experience of travel or living abroad?

4. How do you think the Berlin Wall works as a metaphor in the novel? How does this resonate with your own associations from the time of its fall?

5. The working relationship between Lydia and Kate is a maze of blurred lines. Did you find it dysfunctional? How would you describe Lydia’s personality with respect to Kate? Do you think Kate betrayed Lydia? Have you ever had experience with a similarly fraught employer-employee dynamic?

6. How strongly do you feel the theme of class in the novel? How do you think Kate’s ability to fit into various social strata, while always remaining slightly on the outside, serves her? Does it make her more observant or more confused?

7. What is your perception of Lydia and Clarence’s marriage? Do you know couples who seem to thrive on destructive banter? Do you believe at the end that Lydia and Clarence are ultimately solid despite it all? Or have they undermined one another beyond repair?

8. Would you agree that Lessons in French is very much about family? Does it frustrate you that Kate wants so badly to fit into the Schell family, or do you empathize with her emotionally despite her questionable choices? Why do you think she is so ambivalent about reconnecting with her “true” French family?

9. Kate has a lot of trouble establishing her own point of view among the powerfully influential personalities surrounding her in Paris. At one point she says she feels like she is living inside Picasso painting, assuming multiple perspectives, and lying to everyone. There are several characters who call her on this in various ways: Claudia, Christie, Etienne, and Kate’s own mother, who says, “You and I can handle certain pressures. We don’t feel the need to exaggerate or indulge in, quote unquote, stress. We’re survivors. We have perspective. Remember that” (p. 193). Do you think these motherly words are fair at this point?

10. Etienne’s AIDS diagnosis shocks Kate and Christie. Did you anticipate his illness? Does the unnerving sense of invisible crisis permeate the novel for you? Is it a feeling you associate with that particular moment in time?

11. Kate describes Salman Rushdie as striving to “change his condition” while still inhabiting it (p. 235). Do you think the characters in the novel “inhabit” their conditions even as they try to change? Do you feel this is a statement that can be made, in some way, about most people?

12. Discussing her drawing techniques with Etienne, Kate says, “I don’t change things. I see them. I have a talent for seeing” (p. 163). Would you agree with her assessment, and do you think it is true of her personal interactions? Is her way of seeing also a form of blindness?

13. Kate’s final observation of herself, after she has broken up with Olivier and left the Schell family having returned to her own, is that she is “no longer accent-free to the point of invisibility” (p. 337). How do you feel her accent developed throughout the story? Was the progression narratively satisfying? Realistic? Was her accent - or lack thereof - symbolic to you?

14. Has there been a time in your own life analogous to the year Kate spends in Lessons in French, when you found yourself in a foreign set of circumstances and had to adapt? Were you influenced artistically or intellectually? Did you come across whole new facets of human nature? How does Kate’s journey resonate with you?

Notes From the Author to the Bookclub

No notes at this time.

Book Club Recommendations

Member Reviews

Overall rating:
 
There are no user reviews at this time.
Rate this book
MEMBER LOGIN
Remember me
BECOME A MEMBER it's free

Now serving over 80,000 book clubs & ready to welcome yours. Join us and get the Top Book Club Picks of 2022 (so far).

SEARCH OUR READING GUIDES Search
Search




FEATURED EVENTS
PAST AUTHOR CHATS
JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Get free weekly updates on top club picks, book giveaways, author events and more
Please wait...