| 3 Reasons to Join | ||
|
1. Live Book Club Bestseller List
2. Book Club Planner with reading guide database 3. Book Reviews by Book Clubs Learn more... Become a member...it's free |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
| Authors & Publishers | ||
|
Feature your book on BookMovement! Click here to find out more! |
|
|
|
|
|
Search Reading Guides:
BKMT READING GUIDES
Water for Elephants: A Novel
by Sara Gruen
Published: 2006-05-26
Hardcover: 335 pages
- 294 members reading this now
- 59 clubs reading this now
- 20 members told 36 friends about this book.
- 143 members have read this book
Recommended to book clubs
by 41 of 45 members.
by 41 of 45 members.
With its spotlight on elephants, Gruen's romantic page-turner hinges on the human-animal bonds that drove her debut and its sequel (Riding Lessons and Flying Changes)—but without the mass appeal that horses hold. The novel, told in flashback by nonagenarian Jacob Jankowski, recounts the wild and wonderful...
Also available in:
AMAZON OFFER
List Price:
$23.95
Amazon's Price:
$16.29
You Save:
$7.66 (32%)
Clubs who read this book also discussed:
Introduction
With its spotlight on elephants, Gruen's romantic page-turner hinges on the human-animal bonds that drove her debut and its sequel (Riding Lessons and Flying Changes)—but without the mass appeal that horses hold. The novel, told in flashback by nonagenarian Jacob Jankowski, recounts the wild and wonderful period he spent with the Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth, a traveling circus he joined during the Great Depression. When 23-year-old Jankowski learns that his parents have been killed in a car crash, leaving him penniless, he drops out of Cornell veterinary school and parlays his expertise with animals into a job with the circus, where he cares for a menagerie of exotic creatures[...] He also falls in love with Marlena, one of the show's star performers—a romance complicated by Marlena's husband, the unbalanced, sadistic circus boss who beats both his wife and the animals Jankowski cares for. Despite her often clichéd prose and the predictability of the story's ending, Gruen skillfully humanizes the midgets, drunks, rubes and freaks who populate her bookExcerpt
Prologue
Only three people were left under the red and white awning of the grease joint: Grady, me, and the fry cook. Grady and I sat at a battered wooden table, each facing a burger on a dented tin plate. The cook was behind the counter, scraping his griddle with the edge of a spatula. He had turned off the fryer some time ago, but the odor of grease lingered.
...
view entire excerpt...
Discussion Questions
From the Publisher:
1. To what extent do the chapters concerning the elderly Jacob enhance the chapters recounting the young Jacob’s experiences with the Benzini Brothers circus? In what ways do the chapters about the young Jacob contribute to a deeper understanding of the elderly Jacob’s life?
2. How does the novel’s epigraph, the quote from Dr. Seuss’s Horton Hatches the Egg, apply to the novel? What are the roles and importance of faithfulness and loyalty in Water for Elephants? In what ways does Gruen contrast the antagonisms and cruelties of circus life with the equally impressive loyalties and instances of caring?
3. Who did you, upon reading the prologue, think murdered August? What effect did that opening scene of chaos and murder have on your reception of the story that follows?
4. In connection with Jacob’s formal dinner with August and Marlena in their stateroom, Jacob remarks, “August is gracious, charming, and mischievous” (page 93). To what extent is this an adequate characterization of August? How would you expand upon Jacob’s observation? How would you characterize August? Which situations in the novel reveal his true character?
5. August says of Marlena, “Not everyone can work with liberty horses. It’s a God-given talent, a sixth sense, if you will” (page 94). Both August and Jacob recognize Marlena’s skills, her “sixth sense,” in working with
the horses. In what ways does that sixth sense attract each man? How do August and Jacob differ in terms of the importance each places on Marlena’s abilities?
6. After Jacob puts Silver Star down, August talks with him about the reality of the circus. “The whole thing’s illusion, Jacob,” he says, “and there’s nothing wrong with that. It’s what people want from us. It’s what they expect” (page 104). How does Gruen contrast the worlds of
reality and illusion in the novel? Is there anything wrong with pandering to people’s need for illusion? Why do we crave the illusions that the circus represents?
7. Reflecting on the fact that his platitudes and stories don’t hold his children’s interest, the elderly Jacob notes, “My real stories are all out of date. So what if I can speak firsthand about the Spanish flu, the advent of the automobile, world wars, cold wars, guerrilla wars, and Sputnik—that’s all ancient history now. But what else do I have to offer?” (page 110). How might we learn to appreciate the stories and life lessons of our elders and encourage people younger than ourselves to appreciate our own?
8. Looking at himself in the mirror, the old Jacob tries “to see beyond the sagging flesh.” But he claims, “It’s no good. . . . I can’t find myself anymore.
When did I stop being me?” (page 111). How would you answer
that question for Jacob or any individual, or for yourself?
9. In what ways and to what degree do Uncle Al’s maneuvers and practices regarding the defunct Fox Brothers circus reflect traditional American business practices? How would you compare his behavior with that of major businessmen and financiers of today? What alternative actions would you prefer?
10. As he lies on his bedroll, after his night with Barbara and Nell, Jacob cannot empty his mind of troubling visions, and he reflects that “the more distressing the memory, the more persistent its presence” (page 143). How might the elderly Jacob’s memories corroborate or contradict this observation? What have been your experiences and observations in this regard?
11. In his Carnival of the Animals, Ogden Nash wrote, “Elephants are useful friends.” In what ways is Rosie a “useful” friend? What is Rosie’s role in the events that follow her acquisition by Uncle Al?
12. After Jacob successfully coaches August in Polish commands for Rosie, he observes, “It’s only when I catch Rosie actually purring under August’s loving ministrations that my conviction starts to crumble. And what I’m left looking at in its place is a terrible thing” (page 229).
What is Jacob left “looking at,” how does it pertain to August’s personality and Jacob’s relationship with August, and what makes it a “terrible thing”?
13. How did you react to the redlighting of Walter and Camel, and eight others, off the trestle? How might we see Uncle Al’s cutthroat behavior as “an indictment of a lifetime spent feigning emotions to make a buck” (in the words of one reviewer)?
14. After the collapse of the Benzini Brothers circus and Uncle Al’s having “done a runner” (page 314), Jacob realizes, “Not only am I unemployed and homeless, but I also have a pregnant woman, bereaved dog, elephant, and eleven horses to take care of” (page 317). What expectations did you entertain for Jacob and Marlena’s—and their menagerie’s— future after they leave the Benzini Brothers circus? How do the elderly Jacob’s memories of Marlena and their life together con- firm or alter those expectations?
15. At the end of the novel, Jacob exclaims, “So what if I’m ninety-three? . . . why the hell shouldn’t I run away with the circus?” (page 331). What would you project to be the elderly Jacob’s experiences after he runs away with the circus the second time? How does his decision reflect what we have learned about his early years?
16. Sara Gruen has said that the “backbone” of her novel “parallels the biblical story of Jacob,” in the book of Genesis. On the first night after his leaving Cornell, for example, Jacob—as did his biblical namesake— lies “back on the bank, resting my head on a flat stone” (page 23). In what other ways does Water for Elephants parallel the story of the biblical Jacob? How do the names of many of the characters reflect names of characters in the biblical account?
17. In the words of one reviewer, Water for Elephants “explores . . . the pathetic grandeur of the Depression-era circus.” In what ways and to what extent do the words “pathetic grandeur” describe the world that Gruen creates in her novel?
Suggested by Members
How impactful is the prologue to the overall book? Would your views of the unfolding story change without reading the prologue?
by BellaBella (see profile) 05/22/09Did you feel the character of Marlena was fully developed? Why or why not?
by jillschwadron (see profile) 06/18/09is jacob's story true? how does old age, loss, etc. effect our memories?
knowing most of our bodies will live longer than our minds, how do you hope to be treated? where? by whom?
by holland (see profile) 09/12/09Discussion of the menagerie sequence repeated in both the beginning and the ending.
Depth of relationships and quality of life.
by EDiggins48 (see profile) 09/25/09
Book Club Recommendations
Recommended to book clubs by 41 of 45 members.
Fun Food to Serve
by BellaBella (see profile) 05/22/09To celebrate to book, our book club members brought food you would find at the circus like: popcorn, peanuts, hot dogs, cotton candy and other items that related to the book such as watermelon and Circus Animal Crackers.
A wonderful adventurous mystery like this takes time to read.
by csparks (see profile) 09/19/09Leave yourself plenty of time to savor this book.
Member Reviews
Overall rating:
How would you rate this book? Member ratings:
"Great Book Club Read"by jamstein (see profile) 09/04/07
Our entire book club loved this book. We loved the characters and we all especially loved the ending. Highly recommend.
"A great book, full of strange detail and characters"by MartyA (see profile) 01/26/07
This book is one of the best my club has read in the past year. The discussion over the book was lively and lnteresting. Everyone in the group enjoyed this book. Sara Gruen's writing is evocative and,... (read more)
"Beautifully written,captivating story"by bookbags (see profile) 02/23/07
You will not be able to put this book down. Gruen weaves a beautiful tale with all the elements- intrigue, romance, suspense, history, and relationships. Highly recommended.
"The author actually makes you want to read about a circus."by carolemathias (see profile) 03/21/07
This is the best book I've read in several years. An animal lovers, love story. The reader is drawn deeper and deeper into the life of Jacob. You are completely involved with the characters until the... (read more)
"Wonderful story of love and life under the big top. Beautifully told and researched."by linlo (see profile) 03/26/07
"Refreshing with some surprises"by glombard (see profile) 04/02/07
Who doesn't love the circus and the many layers of characters involved in a production? The author's description painted a very good picture place and time - we could almost smell the peanuts. This... (read more)
"VGreat read-I look forward to reading more of this authors books"by carla.ross (see profile) 04/02/07
The author has a great style of writting. Nothing was over the top. Everthing seemed to be real enough to believe. There was great anticipation from one chapter to the another. The contrast from old... (read more)
"Loved It! Can't wait to pass this book around!"by DAnn29 (see profile) 04/18/07
Great book, tragic, sad, silly, heartwarming, thoughtful, etc....highly recomend this one. I am waiting for my turn to pick a book for our club, this one will be it. READ IT.
"The story is ripe for many types of discussion."by pageturner (see profile) 05/01/07
I found the story not only romantic in the "love story" but so much romance in the adventure Jacob Jankowski's life centered around. This was an incredibly visual story for me. I felt as though I had... (read more)
"Very interesting - both past and present life of characters."by gmcisaac (see profile) 05/11/07
Brings back the wonderful carnival /circus experiences had as a child...the ambiance of the Big Top and animals, etc was extremely well done. Sara Gruen does a great job of doing her homework with respect... (read more)
"growing old"by susan48 (see profile) 05/22/07
The book was great. The book goes back and forth of the narrator. He is 93 living in a nursing home. He's mind, and he's memory is not what it used to be. He then talks about he's past when he is about... (read more)
"Unbelievable! Loved every moment of my sleepless nights turning the pages of this novel."by mac2jeter (see profile) 05/25/07
"Excellent Book - A Must Read"by Wendy56 (see profile) 05/31/07
I started to read this book with some trepidation, but once I started it, I couldn't put it down. It is filled with all of life's trials, joys, passions, and sadnesses.
"A captivating exploration of mankind and animals"by dchase21 (see profile) 05/31/07
An excellent book for discussion. The multilayered story line seamlessly takes the reader from the depression era circus life to the despondency of life in a nursing home. Loyalty, love, betrayal, compassion,... (read more)
"Easy, interesting read"by julialily (see profile) 06/02/07
Everyone in my book club enjoyed the book but I found us talking very little about it. While it was interesting and a fast read, it lacked the necessary depth and controversy to qualify as a spectacular... (read more)
"Longer then 10 Characters"by Sarah.Bergagnini (see profile) 06/06/07
The good parts balance out the bad parts. Not a strong main character. The elephant was the best part of the whole book.
"I really enjoyed the story save for the very end, which was OK."by danicaart (see profile) 06/06/07
I actually give it higher than 3 stars, maybe 4 1/2 but it wouldn't let me change it.
"Deserves its spot on the bestsellers lists!"by Melon_e03 (see profile) 06/09/07
I bought this book simply because I kept seeing it in all the bookstores. It was such a good read that I was surprised. I have lent it out twice now and both people loved it! Other reviewers are right,... (read more)
"The world of the circus in the early '30s"by frsaad (see profile) 06/12/07
Describing what this book is about hardly does credit. It's a very good look at complex relationships - people to people and people to animal.
"A good read, but not a classic!"by Martini (see profile) 06/16/07
Some interesting characters, but what do would one expect in a story about circus people? A super east read, so a good book for the summer when everyone is busy busy. The best part is the ending.....I... (read more)
"wonderful--entertaining and thoughful"by Mjackson (see profile) 06/28/07
I loved this book--and it is on it's way to many others--after last month reading The Road--it was just fun and refreshing and well written and the BEST story!
"Original and a fascinating ride back to the Depression-era and to the world of modern nursing home."by BonSasso (see profile) 06/28/07
"lively book club discussion!"by rcw (see profile) 07/11/07
This book provided ample discussion topics, not only in the discussion questions provided at the back of the book, but just in the course of the character development, plot, and author's notes. Excellent.... (read more)
"looking at an old life to revitalize an existing one"by imain (see profile) 07/14/07
I love this book. The story is gripping: a young man joins the circus after the death of his parents and falls in love with a married woman. But the framework of the story is brilliant, with the aged... (read more)
"Captivating from the beginning to end..."by lptucker411 (see profile) 07/14/07
You know it's a good book when I wake up at 5 a.m. and decide to go finish it instead of getting more sleep! I had a friend recommend it - decided to see for myself and was not disappointed. A nice... (read more)
"Easily one of the best books that I have ever read..."by ktamerlano (see profile) 07/16/07
This book was one that really sucked me in and when I was reading it I felt like I was transported into the story. It is beautifully written and the story is very gripping. I don't want to say too much... (read more)
"Excellent read"by debbieshapiro (see profile) 07/21/07
I was captured from the first page to the last. Gruen does an excellent job of holding your interest in history and keeping you in suspense. The ending will surprise you!
"Jacob takes us back to his life as a young man in the world of a circus."by Kierstin (see profile) 07/21/07
"This book deserves all the attention it's getting!"by LisaMM (see profile) 07/21/07
Very well written and researched book about a travelling circus in the depression era. Sara Gruen can really tell a story! All the oddities of the circus come to life and feel very authentic and believable.... (read more)
"It has many layers to several of the characters that are great discussion topics."by lmscholz (see profile) 07/23/07
My book club really like this book. The characters had several layers that made the book very interesting, sensitive and enlighting.
"I loved this book"by lmarym (see profile) 07/24/07
It was a very touching read, I wish my father's stay in the nursing home could have ended the same way.
"Circus love story"by ellentambo (see profile) 08/01/07
Wondrfully written, fun love story. Also lots of information about the circus and what it was like in the early 20th century.
"Welcome to the circus - you won't want to leave!"by sgeekie (see profile) 08/04/07
The first of my "bookclub" experiences and I hope they are all this satisfying. Deftly told within a world you find hard not become totally immersed in. A haunting insight of growing old from the 90 or... (read more)
"An outstanding read"by Sharon_Morgan (see profile) 08/10/07
I would have never picked up this book in the store had it not been for my reading club. I am so pleased that I had the opportunity to read it. A lovely story that just jumped off the pages into my... (read more)
"Great discussion book, this novel contained subject matter new to most of our group which is why it was so interesting"by cherylynnmartens (see profile) 08/14/07
Our book club enjoyed Water for Elephants: A Novel. It was not our favorite book of all time but it was a lite summer read which was interesting and easy to follow. The author did a good job researching... (read more)
"An interesting novel about relationships between people and animals in a circus atmosphere."by dianedrake (see profile) 08/15/07
I loved this book. I went to the circus as a child and the book brought back memories. When I read the summary on the back and looked at the title and picture I wasn't sure I wanted to read it. I am... (read more)
"Enjoyed from beginning to end."by doerayme (see profile) 08/16/07
The author did a great job of describing what it was like to be ninety or ninety three. I really liked this book.
"Lots of discussion regarding aging, loyalty, depression era life."by mamatimms (see profile) 08/16/07
"It brings out the values of the past such as loyalty and committment"by farmgirlind (see profile) 08/16/07
A great book. Bridges the generations and treats the reader to wonder of circus life.
"A great story--page turner til the end."by momom248 (see profile) 08/16/07
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I loved the circus theme behind it and the love story. It was a real page turn and I was very disappointed to see it end. I hope to read more by this author.
"This book was written extremely well, great descriptions and characters."by rms516 (see profile) 08/17/07
Everyone loved this book in our book club because of the way the author seamlessly switched from present day to past events, great descriptions that you could easily picture in your mind, and its unusual... (read more)
"Great story about a traveling circus during the depression."by gazzingo (see profile) 08/17/07
Everyone liked the story of a young man's experiences with a traveling circus during the depression. There was humor, suspense, sorrow and joy in the story. Jacob was a plucky young man and also in his... (read more)
"Besides getting areal feel for the early days of the circus you get a first hand view of getting older with all its frustrations andlonliness. Makes you think twice about your interactionls with the"by mwerney (see profile) 08/17/07
"Great book!"by jendicus (see profile) 08/26/07
Interesting details of circus life in the 1930's during the depression. Many of the stories contained within are drawn from real life. Very interesting plot, hard to put down. Great read.
"The Ford Book Is Outstanding"by carfan00 (see profile) 09/02/07
This book reminds me of the Ford book. Has anyone read the new Ford book - Ford and the American Dream by Clifton Lambreth,Mary Calia,Melissa Webb and Pat Doyle. This book outlines the perils facing the... (read more)
"A boy joins the circus."by interbrook (see profile) 09/03/07
I put the wrong star up. I LOVED this book. When I found out it was about a boy joining the circus. I groaned. But fortunatly, I read on and I loved it. Probably one of my favorit books now. Read and... (read more)
"I'm in love with Jacob's father!!!"by patsy (see profile) 09/04/07
This book is a combination of many things. Humor, love, sadness, reality, history, etc.. Highly recommend it especially to those of us who are animal lovers. Am anxious to read more of Sara Gruen's work.... (read more)
"A man in his 90's looks back at his life in the circus; at his life as a young man and his life in the present , in a nursing home. The story spans many years, and the surprise ending will make you wa"by callymine (see profile) 09/05/07
This books is wonderfully written. The image it paints of circus life is so real that you can smell the cotton candy and hear the ringmaster's whip. It is about all kinds of love...romantic love that spans... (read more)
"story of love and adventure during the years of the depression."by joyce35shopper (see profile) 09/06/07
I recommend this book because it is a different kind of story with an interesting concept.A bery good read!
"It's a novel that depicts one man's journey living and working for the circus."by Leeny (see profile) 09/09/07
I found the novel very entertaing and it kept my interest. The novel wasn't my favorite that our book club has read but I'm glad that we read it. I wasn't aware about all of the going-ons behind the... (read more)
"Great characters and a wonderful read."by ann (see profile) 09/09/07
Done in a story within a story format that really keeps it interesting. The author develops the characters so well, and you feel like you know them.
"The book will lend itself to good discussion and opinions."by princeirene (see profile) 09/10/07
The book is intriguing and exciting. The world that Jacob Jankowski had lived in prior to the tragedy was so different. It is an informative look at a world, the early days of traveling circuses, that... (read more)
"An interesting, historical circus novel with a good romance to boot."by esparkhu (see profile) 09/12/07
"A fantastic page turner from the era of the Great Depression."by amills (see profile) 09/12/07
Our book club used this wonderful depiction of circus trains to discuss topics such as aging, families, relationships, mental illness, animal cruelty, etc. A believeable viewpoint, incredible twists, and... (read more)
"the story of a young aspiring vet during the depression years who suddenly lost everything and got thrown intot he life of the traveling circus."by pcv120150 (see profile) 09/14/07
a book that comes alive with the sounds and smells of the circus life in the depression years. The characters are marvelous. Very well written. I hated to see the last page come. A real page-turner.
"Story grabs you from the start"by mztupelo (see profile) 09/15/07
I truly enjoyed this book. I found the writing to be so smooth to seem almost effortless. The details of life in a circus during the depression never faltered and the characters were very interesting.... (read more)
"Love, growing older, circus life, .. this amazing book has it all!"by jgillin (see profile) 09/15/07
This isn't just about a circus; it's about survival, love, growing old and standing up for those weaker than ourselves. I loved this book! The story was riveting; from the very beginning, I couldn't put... (read more)
"I absolutely loved this book and recommend it with great enthusiasm"by claudiazee (see profile) 09/16/07
"Great on so many levels!!"by kdy12570 (see profile) 09/19/07
I was so pleasantly surprised by this book. It was so much more than I thought it would be. There are many different levels of the book to discuss and it made you feel good at the end. I was hooked... (read more)
"A great story that is a fast, easy read. Ms. Gruen's research was evident. Enjoyed by all club members."by lyngeib (see profile) 09/19/07
I really enjoyed this book. As an animal lover, it was difficult to read at times, and reaffirmed my feelings about circuses and rodeos. Ms. Gruen did a great job researching circuses during the Depression.... (read more)
"A young man learns to live and an old man learns to die; life is a circus."by missgavacs (see profile) 09/20/07
A pleasant read that touches on the weighty topics of life with a soft hand. The book's plot and movement focus on several pairs of character foils, which gives book clubs much to discuss.
"A fun discussion for all members"by cprahler (see profile) 09/21/07
This book led to an interesting discussion which included a variety of topics from what we remembered about circuses as children to nursing home conditions. Everyone seemed to get in on the discussion.... (read more)
"Provided much discussion"by apleser (see profile) 09/22/07
I really liked the book, was a fast read for me, and provided much material for the meeting as many of our members had varying views of the story. Most people were able to find parts of the book that... (read more)
"A nursing home-bound man recalls his early years with a Depression-era circus"by CathyM (see profile) 09/26/07
This book is touching and sort of sneaks up on you. For all of us who are afraid of getting old, it makes you think. It will make you think about how you view and treat the elders that you know currently. The... (read more)
"Old man recounts his experience in the Circus as a youth."by LMH (see profile) 09/29/07
Enjoyable, perhaps a deeper meaning to the ending than I originally thought.
"Lots of enlightening moments and discussions."by Madam Secretary (see profile) 09/29/07
We thought this book was terrific. We had many eye-opening discussions and many revelations came out about the characters and their actions. We had a great discussion comparing the book's characters... (read more)
"Cannot understand what the WOW factor is about this novel."by kpeters (see profile) 10/02/07
I found this book interesting but not something I would choose to recommend to others. The only benefit I found from reading the book was a different perspective on the elderly. The author did an excellent... (read more)
"Life in the circus during the Great Depression."by tompatrice (see profile) 10/06/07
One of the best books I've ever read. Sara Gruen paints a detailed picture of life in the traveling "Big Top" during the '30's. The characters are so real, so compelling, that you can't put the book... (read more)
"A great read!"by fiibmrocks (see profile) 10/09/07
I couldn't put this book down until I read the last page!
"An old man reminisces about experiences he had as a young man as a vet in the circus"by charladury (see profile) 10/11/07
Great read! Wonderful character descriptions and full depth story.
"Circus life during the depression era."by gaeta17 (see profile) 10/11/07
This was a good story, very interesting if you don't know anything about circus life. A nice weave between past and present. Well done.
"Great story!"by ROSA1979 (see profile) 10/16/07
I loved this book. Everything was so fascinating - I loved learning about the circus, the animals, the rubes, the train - everything! I thought Jacob was wonderful, past & present. Really great all around... (read more)
"Topics of circus, life in the depression era and issues related to aging offer good discussion"by marylee0526 (see profile) 10/18/07
"Interesting facts about circus life, in an earlier time, mixed with present day life in a nursing home."by scribread (see profile) 10/18/07
The nursing home narrative rang true to me, the circus life, although interesting, did not engage me. Most characters seemed like one dimensional plot devices to me. My book club enjoyed this book a... (read more)
"Loved the book. Easy read.very entrtaining about the life of the circus during the depression."by rivvie (see profile) 10/18/07
"a great love story"by cdlooney (see profile) 10/19/07
This is a beautiful love story ... not a trashy romance, but a story about a great love. Jacob loves both Marlena and the circus ... as well as many animals. This was a great book!
"Awesome read!"by cameronne (see profile) 10/24/07
This book was fascinating and heartbreaking. I highly recommend it!
"weird and interesting"by clarestella (see profile) 10/26/07
I loved this book. It has unusual characters and certainly a different setting.
"all members of our book club enjoyed this book"by katjakrull (see profile) 10/26/07
We were swept away and all of us remebered when we once wanted to run away with the circus.
"You will press this onto spouses, teens, parents and strangers: It's that good and that universal"by kcurry (see profile) 10/28/07
A book that catalogues a time in our history too few remember with gritty, breathtaking detail. It begins in our modern-day "depression"world of the so-called retirement home, returns in memory to the... (read more)
"A GREAT Story to Fall in Love With!"by jaseifert (see profile) 10/28/07
Not a classic but great just the same. The characters are easy to love and hate, even the minor ones, but I won't say which is which. Sara Gruen does brings you into circus life without trying to hard;... (read more)
"A GREAT Story to Fall in Love With!"by jaseifert (see profile) 10/28/07
Not a classic but great just the same. The characters are easy to love and hate, even the minor ones, but I won't say which is which. Sara Gruen does brings you into circus life without trying to hard;... (read more)
"Light, fun and entertaining read"by ahamblin (see profile) 10/30/07
This book was an easy and entertaining read. I especially enjoyed the prologue by the author describing her research and how many of the book's tales were based on true stories of the circus. The book... (read more)
"Vety good read"by dcraggs (see profile) 11/02/07
Enjoyed the story and characters. Not much for the circus, but this gave new insight.
"Everyone in the group enjoyed this book."by ChathamBookClub (see profile) 11/04/07
Good book for discussion.
"Interesting and entertaining"by bskaat (see profile) 11/08/07
A very satisfying read. The book was interesting and well researched. The ending was well crafted. I highly recommend this book.
"This book is about the story of a troubled young man who tries to escape from his life and ends up joining the circus. The story is told in past and prsent by the narrator as both an old man and the"by bookworm15 (see profile) 11/09/07
I Loved It! I Found Myself Escaping Away Right Into The Story. It's A Great Read For All.
"Absolutely Love this Book!!"by WandaO224 (see profile) 11/09/07
One of the best books I've read in a long time. Very well written.
"Water for Elephants"by CABarney56 (see profile) 11/17/07
The members gave mixed reviews on this book. We found it genuinely interesting and a change of pace from our usual reading. Some thought it was a little unbelievable, but all in all, it got an A-okay... (read more)
"Great look into the past of a person and a passing tradition of entertainment"by celticwitch (see profile) 11/26/07
Being of a "certain" age, the main character appealed to me. Remembrance of things past tied closely with the present made this book a good read. The ending is so fitting!
"Delightful!"by taylor.amt (see profile) 11/27/07
This book was a wonderful journey from the first page to the last. Wonderful characters, exciting setting, and a plot that pulled me through the book.
"Sara Gruen tells a wonderful story"by ladyjane7 (see profile) 12/08/07
Sarah Gruen draws you into a wonderful story of an old-time circus, full of intriguing characters, including a very special elephant named Rosie. Since the story is told in the past and the present, there... (read more)
"a story about the life of a man who survived the depression by working in a circus and is now remembering the impact it had on his life - the most meaningful part"by donnab1 (see profile) 12/11/07
The literary technique of past and present was very effective in presenting this story. The research the author provided for the background of the life in a circus during the depression was impressive.... (read more)
"This book provided alot to discuss from the mistreatment of animals to the fate of many elderly people."by tnewman123 (see profile) 12/11/07
On the whole our book club enjoyed this book. It was hard for many to read about the mistreatment of the animals in the circus, and yet it brought to light a subject that many of us had never explored.... (read more)
"LEarning how to live, love & deal with loss reflections of an elderly man on his youth spent in the circus."by lemke98 (see profile) 12/12/07
Awesome read!
"a wonderful about circus living in the depression and family relations"by SolCristina (see profile) 12/13/07
"Fantastic!!!!"by dawnisgoofy (see profile) 12/13/07
Our club LOVED this book. She really knows how to write with detail that you can actually picture. We highly recommend it!!!!
"Thought provoking book"by marilynnmoore (see profile) 12/16/07
Would never have chosen this book on my own but interesting read for this period of time. I had trouble reading about the animal cruelty so I had to skip over those parts in the book.
"It's a great book about growing old and how the nursing home is a circus."by writingdoctor (see profile) 12/18/07
The Circus Comes to Town--WATER FOR ELEPHANTS by Sara Gruen WATER FOR ELEPHANTS by Sara Gruen (Algonquin Books, 2007). Reviewed by Nancy Yanes Hoffman, www.writingdoctor.typepad.com. EMail: nywriter@rochester.rr.com In... (read more)
"Two stories in one that will mesmorize readers."by ajkhhunter (see profile) 12/20/07
My club loved this book. There wasn't one person who didn't like it. Gruen does an excellent job of blending two stories into one. Characters come to life on the page. This is an excellent and quick... (read more)
"What a great tale of love and the history of the circus"by dtcfife (see profile) 12/22/07
This was one of the best books that I have read in a long time. It was a very interesting tale of how two people whol loved animals fell in love and at the same time really interesting stories of the... (read more)
"Near the top of my list"by cheriann (see profile) 12/28/07
This book was one of my all time favorites. It was very different, as far as the storyline. It was very well written and left great things for discussion. Also made me want to take my kids to the circus... (read more)
"Truly Wonderful Book"by Laura Loanna (see profile) 12/29/07
It is refreshingly easy to read and captivates you immediately. It is very well written and really made me more interested in the history of the circus.
"Absolutely riveting...should be a movie, but read the book first!"by jbschutte (see profile) 01/03/08
I loved this book. It's one of those that grabs you at page one and you don't want to put it down. Cliche, I know, but it fits. Sara Gruen puts you in the circus during the depression and tells the... (read more)
"This was a great book with many opportunities for discussion"by jimsven (see profile) 01/04/08
A very good read!
"We had a good discussion regarding the different layers of the book."by judy (see profile) 01/09/08
Our book club all enjoyed the book. We live in a resort community with many retired and elderly people. We felt it gave us insight into their lives. We like the way the book was written, i.e. the past/present... (read more)
"The book gives much to discuss as to growth and coping with difficult situations in life and taking control of life even in old age."by cheryloconnor (see profile) 01/14/08
The writing is inspired. I am amazed at Sara Guen's understanding of human nature. She is able to show both the good and the bad of people, as well as the complexity of human existence. It is a book... (read more)
"Mr Janlowski, a ninety year old in a nursing home, reflects back on his youth as a veterinarian for a circus."by lamccormick (see profile) 01/14/08
Our group really enjoyed this book. It stimulated much discussion not only about the story, how it was well written and a great read but how we individually look at what is ahead of us as we age. Highly... (read more)
"Jacob, an old circus employee in a nursing home, relives his life in flashbacks"by tnbobi (see profile) 01/15/08
We all loved it. It taught us about the minds of some of the residents of a nursing home and reenforced the idea of a mostly non-caring environment. It gave us a picture of circus life like we had never... (read more)
"fun to read and lots to discuss"by lizbevilacqua (see profile) 01/16/08
This book is full of juxtapositions. Also, it is a good lead in to discuss issues dealing with the elderly, the Great Depression, characters, etc.
"About the circus during the depression."by LezlieSS (see profile) 01/16/08
Everyone in our book club enjoyed this book. It lead to a great discussion as well.
"Story about Circus life"by paulavan1 (see profile) 01/23/08
Enjoyable and easy read. THe Elephant is a remarkable animal!
"different and amusing yet touched with kindness, loyalty and determination"by dlongwell1 (see profile) 01/27/08
"Spectacular!!"by crasnick (see profile) 01/30/08
This book was well liked by all and for different reasons.
"An interesting look at a 90 or 93-year -old man relating his experience as a young man who ran away and"by suzy1965 (see profile) 02/01/08
Our book club enjoyed this book; our discussion covered old age & what happens when you're unable to take care of yourself any longer; the fascination of a Depression-era job working for the circus - able... (read more)
"I enjoyed the book but not quite sure what all the hype is about."by lasuhe (see profile) 02/01/08
First of all, anyone who has not read this book should not read the prologue. If you do, once you get to a certain point in the book you know what's going to happen which loses the shock value of the... (read more)
"A Very Good Book"by fairyflyte (see profile) 02/12/08
Finally, a book that is truly readable, being both entertaining and well written.
"An nice perspective on two stages of life, with a surprise twist at the end."by lsanderoff (see profile) 02/14/08
"I think it's a little dark at times"by khuber (see profile) 02/18/08
I would recommend the book. Everyone thought it was a fast read. However, it has some dark themes.
"Compelling Read"by joleneybean (see profile) 02/19/08
I couldn't put it down! Jacob's character is easy to connect with even though he's in his 90s. You feel like you're right there with him through the whole book. The detail and description of 1930's... (read more)
"Great Read"by Caseykd (see profile) 02/19/08
This book was a very interesting and easy to read book! Our book clube really enjoyed reading and discussing it!
"Easy, enjoyable read with historical flavor."by debie (see profile) 02/21/08
Montana Forever book club members were quick to talk about their circus experiences, the acts, the animals, the cotton candy. The novel was true to how animals were treated, the life style of the circus... (read more)
"Very Interesting look into a different time and place"by cvmom (see profile) 02/21/08
I read this book very quickly. I had a difficult time putting it down. If you enjoy history, and particularily the Depression-era stuff then you will probably like this story. The ending seemed a little... (read more)
"Best discussion of the year"by dglovett (see profile) 02/25/08
This well writiten novel captured the interest of all our members, old and young alike. MANY issues to explore in this novel.
"90+ year old man reflects on his younger life"by lovebooks (see profile) 02/29/08
Jacob is now 93ish and in an assisted living arrangement and his family missed their Sunday to visit which could have made a lesser man miss the one thing he was longing to do visit the circus. Old... (read more)
"Everyone enjoyed it! Finally a book with a happy ending!"by tboat (see profile) 02/29/08
Sara Gruen writes a very descriptive book which draws you in and keeps you wanting more! Loved it!
"A look into the world of a circus during the Depression from the POV of a young veteranarian."by Jamaine (see profile) 03/03/08
"Our book club loved this book."by kathrynhogan (see profile) 03/04/08
Our book club especially loved the nursing home part. Many of us have loved ones in a nursing home and could relate to the story. We felt like the author did a great job of describing the depression... (read more)
"Great book that was hard to put down!"by darkim9 (see profile) 03/09/08
This book would not be one that I would usually read. I really cared for most of the characters and their life story. I liked how Gruen told his entire life story by going back to his younger years and... (read more)
"A Great Read!"by cottagegirls (see profile) 03/10/08
Our group really enjoyed this book. Lots of discussion...one of my favorite book club books.
"Excellent, Interesting, and gripping"by tedro (see profile) 03/12/08
We all enjoyed this unusual, yet exciting take on circus life in the early 1900's. The writer keeps your attention until the very end and gives a remarkable insight into the life of an elderly man. Very... (read more)
"Great way to see the circus life!"by Marcia55 (see profile) 03/13/08
our club really enjoyed this book. I listened to it on cd and enjoyed the main character being read by 2 different men depending on the age in the book. Marcia
"Highly engaging story about life in the circus told through the eyes of the main character who is now an elderly man."by grtimler (see profile) 03/15/08
"Fantastic Book!"by sroberts (see profile) 03/15/08
This was a very moving book which engaged the reader immediately. The chapters that reflected Jacob's years in the nursing home sparked much conversation. This is a great book with many twists and turns... (read more)
"Everyone in the group enjoyed this book."by llray (see profile) 03/19/08
Did not know what to expect, throughly enjoyed the book. Would recomend to anyone.
"Now a fiesty ninety-year-old in a nursing home, Jacob Jankowski remembers the Depression years he spent with the circus, its amazing animals and fascinating people."by bavier (see profile) 03/21/08
Sara Gruen does a beautiful job of pulling together the many important themes running through this unusual book--love, kindness, courage, old age, class arrogance, greed. Amazing animals share the spotlight... (read more)
"Slow start but a great book..."by Kathy1966 (see profile) 03/23/08
This book was difficult at the beginning but then it became one that was hard to put down. it begins with Jacob remembering his life as he lives in a nursing home. I actually listened to it on a book-on-tape... (read more)
"Great! Highly recommend!"by AnitaWorkman (see profile) 03/26/08
I love books where I get to learn a little something. The author researches the circus world of the 20s and 30s and easily brings the experience to the reader.
"The book reviews were misleading as I struggled to finish reading it. Not a compelling read, however, the ending saved face."by sisters (see profile) 03/27/08
"Jacob Jankowski is a veterinary student who joins a travelling circus."by donnaf (see profile) 03/27/08
This book is insightfull as to what everyday life is like for circus roadies and other circus performers and the animals that they perform with within a travelling circus.
"CIRCUS LIFE DURING THE DEPRESSION"by KLOPES (see profile) 03/27/08
The book was well-written and very engaging. It handles the hard life of people on the outside edges of respectability during the Depression. The "sad" life of our main character weaves back and forth... (read more)
"boy meets elephant, boy meets girl...lives happily everafter"by Snuzaroo (see profile) 03/29/08
I thought adding the pictures was a great part of the book. I learned allot of circus history. I like the story line it kept me interested, the various conflicts that went on. My only criticism was i really... (read more)
"Lacked depth"by risserlee (see profile) 03/31/08
Our group generally felt this book was a page turner, but offered little in the way of depth in its characters. The plot was interesting, but at times implausible.
"Great writing!"by Kburleson (see profile) 04/01/08
I would have to say this was one of my all time favorites. The book is well written, and holds your attention from start to finish. This is one of those books you have a hard time putting down.
"A dramatic review of an old man looking back at his past with the circus"by asthepagesturn (see profile) 04/05/08
A fabulous book! Riveting--Gruen can sustain a readers interest. Great discussion book.
"(As a young man, Jacob Jankowski was tossed by fate onto a rickety train that was home to the Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth. It was the early part of the great Depression, and for Ja"by zruderman (see profile) 04/05/08
"a very realistic yet mystical portrait of the behind the scenes traveling circus durring the depression era. it is very vivid and hard to put down. it has a love story. but, the most amazing thing i c"by taradave31 (see profile) 04/06/08
see above. all in all i loved this book. my review is in the summary. the only part about this book is i felt it had an unrealistic ending. although a happy ending i thought. but, having the whole rest... (read more)
"WE all loved it!"by marlat (see profile) 04/21/08
This is one of the rare books that all of us totally love! The richness of the writing, the characters, the story, all unique and captivating!
"Everyone in the group enjoyed the book"by lghedge (see profile) 04/25/08
I thought the book was well written. I felt I was there with the characters. The historical aspect was very interesting.
"Great easy read on an unusual topic"by laboudara (see profile) 04/28/08
I really enjoyed this book. It was a pretty easy read but kept my interest. An unusual story about a topic with which I had no familiarity. Our group had a really lively discussion about the story and... (read more)
"A great book for discussion! Loved the twists and turns of circus life!"by kileyri9 (see profile) 04/29/08
What an interesting view of the circus! I don't think any of our members will ever look at a circus in the same light again! We loved the character development and shocking twists and turns!
"The life of a man who lived with a circus."by iula7 (see profile) 05/02/08
This was a good discussion book. Everyone enjoyed it.
"Good human tale of life and its adversities"by doodlebugsmom (see profile) 05/08/08
My book club enjoyed this story of a man's life and how he responded to misery and happiness. The book vividly introduces the reader to animals with characters that shine; as well as gives the reader... (read more)
"Interesting topic and writing well done!"by Ingerkoppenhaver (see profile) 05/13/08
Our book club thoroughly enjoyed Water for Elephants. One of the highlights of the book is actually not the story of the circus but the in depth look at the main character's stay in the nursing home.... (read more)
"What a great book!"by suebooksri (see profile) 05/16/08
My book club loved this book. We all enjoyed reading it and our discussion brought a lot of interesting things to the table. Not what we expected and a really great book with great characters. I would... (read more)
"Great book! Highly recommended"by chrissie60ca (see profile) 05/22/08
Everyone in our club really enjoyed this book. Great choice!
"A Great Book"by Diane860 (see profile) 05/29/08
Water for Elephants is a page turner. Most members of our club finished the book in a few days and most gave it our highest book rating. The story Jacob Jankowski tells is engaging. We spent a lot of... (read more)
"Great Read!!"by karenannmoore (see profile) 05/29/08
I loved this book for a variety of reasons... great writing, and it was so interesting learning about circus culture in the 30's, and I loved reading the parts when Jacob was 90 or 93.
"Excellent read!"by Lissa333 (see profile) 05/29/08
This is one of the best books I have ever read. I was a little weary, as reading about 1930s circus life was not terribly appealing. This book had been recommended however, so I brought it up to the book... (read more)
"very inciteful, helps understand what elderly people may be thinking"by suemoros (see profile) 05/29/08
I found this book very interesting. Learned about nursing homes and circuses during the depression.
"The audio book was awesome!"by ecowan0730 (see profile) 05/30/08
What an imaginative story! Very refreshing - I loved every part of it! The audio book was very well done - with two narrators. I recommend it for a road trip with significant other. It sparked great... (read more)
"Fun and interesting"by smarcott (see profile) 06/02/08
I felt like I was there with the characters. Very well written book with fantastic imagery.
"very different, unexpected story. Great reading."by jobook (see profile) 06/09/08
Great story of being delt a life changing blow, having to grow up fast in not so nice surroundings. Learning to survive with what you have, and then to achieve your goals later on. Then to look back and... (read more)
"a great book"by nancy10 (see profile) 06/21/08
This book gives a wonderful perspective of an aging man looking back on his life. It also provides a historical view of the circus during it's heyday (during the Depresssion). It is multi-layered with... (read more)
"It just drew me in"by Rollabren (see profile) 06/25/08
I have to admit that when I first read the summary of this book I wasn't overly excited to read it. But I figured so many people couldn't be wrong so I gave it a try. I didn't realize how hooked I was... (read more)
"Great insight into circuses and the depression!"by melchi381 (see profile) 06/30/08
Very vivid descriptions and detail throughtout! Full of tragedy and reality mixed into one. Great book for discussion.
"If a book can make me both laugh and cry more than twice I like the book"by Allard (see profile) 07/04/08
"An easy read but not much depth"by idahotheta (see profile) 07/05/08
The book was an easy read but I found the characters and story lacking depth. The characters could have been very interesting but they just weren't developed enough.
"Life can change in a heartbeat and does for Jacob who after his parents death joins the travelling circus. Facinating plot and interesting look into the circus culture of the 1930s."by amylho (see profile) 07/05/08
"TRUE FIND, GREAT READ"by BREE_23 (see profile) 07/07/08
This was a truly great read. It held my interest and was very descriptive. I would rate this a 5 star book.!! :)
"A circus in the 1930's."by courtneyfletcher (see profile) 07/07/08
This is a great read. I highly recommend it. You will love the story. Very moving.
"You will enjoy the spirit of this old man and his memory"by bellasmile2 (see profile) 07/13/08
I really enjoyed this book. A great love story told by an aging man in a nursing home. Its about his adventures as a vet in the circus. I learned we should have more conversations wiht elderly people,... (read more)
"A great book for discussion, and one I'll be reading again."by A Lynette Parsons (see profile) 07/15/08
The fully realized characters, the details of daily life in Depression-era America, and especially Gruen's handling of Jacob at two very different stages of life were compelling and a joy to read. Don't... (read more)
"Our book club enjoyed reading this book"by lejeunemary (see profile) 07/15/08
The story was well told through the perspective of an elderly man. It captivated me from the first chapter. It brought back memories of the circuses when I was a child.
"Loved it!"by lauragillis (see profile) 07/16/08
I don't know that I would have picked this book up in the bookstore - but I'm glad we choose to read it as it was wonderful. Vividly written. Lot's of points for discussion.
"A 93 year old man tells of his current life and the strange events that led to his life in the circus. It's a love story between him and the ringmaster's wife and the animals in the menagerie."by Beige (see profile) 07/17/08
The book is well written and researched. The reader gets a view of life in a nursing home and in flash backs to the circus. The themes of kindness and cruelty to animals and humans runs through out the... (read more)
"I want an elephant for Christmas!"by mel29 (see profile) 07/21/08
This was the second time I read this book and loved it just as much as the first time!!! It's actually two stories in one: young Jacob and old Jacob. It's a timeless story that looks at the moral compasses... (read more)
"Not the feel good book of the year!"by jdcox21 (see profile) 07/28/08
I heard so much about how great this book was but when I read it, I was rather disappointed. This book tells the story of a young guy Jacob whose world falls apart on him virtually overnight. He runs... (read more)
"Once in a lifetime adventure for a young man, set in a cricus in the great depression."by ansparker (see profile) 08/03/08
An unexpected treat. Very creative and unique, I enjoyed the story told by the author.
"1930's circus life, love"by treynolds (see profile) 08/03/08
Although I would probably not have picked this for myself, it turned out to be a great book. It was a very engaging story and was easy to read but also made you think. Good pick for a book club.
"Excellent History, with story that evokes a huge amount of discussion"by auddiemae (see profile) 08/05/08
"life of a young single man in the circus life of the Great Depression"by lherrero (see profile) 08/06/08
The book was a delight to read. Although there were scenes which contained great cruelty (to both circus animals and the workers), which I found difficult to read, I felt there was likely a great deal... (read more)
"A fast read with interesting characters and non-fiction aspects about the circus"by acronen (see profile) 08/07/08
Our club read this as the third and final book (we only meet in the summer). No one in the group loved it, but all of us liked it. We all were disappointed in the ending, and felt Gruen needed to expand... (read more)
"Interesting glimpse into the nuanced lives of circus folk during the Depression."by suzyque (see profile) 08/07/08
Our club pretty much agreed that this was a good read. A few members were looking for more out of the book, but most of us felt that the author captured the circus world with lots of detailed work. We... (read more)
"LOVED IT, LOVED IT, LOVED IT!"by darcieturgeon (see profile) 08/08/08
Have you ever wanted to un-read a book? When I finished this book, I wished I could un-read it so that I could read it again. I loved the present-past-present dialogue, male perspective from a female... (read more)
"excellent history/great for discussion"by auddiemae (see profile) 08/10/08
I have read this book for two different bookclubs, and both times we had lively discussions of the characters. This book is definately different than most we read, and was a welcome change. The book... (read more)
"Not at all what I expected! My club hasn't read it yet but they should!"by Delaine (see profile) 08/17/08
A mesmerizing story full of adventure, I couldn't put this book down. It made me happy, somehow. The end was fantastic - perfect! I want to read it again.
"Excellent book.,"by sskopaz (see profile) 08/27/08
I completely enjoyed this book. The author's research was very good. Gruen brought you back to the Depression era with ease and presented circus life with great detail. Our book club appreciated the... (read more)
"Our book club discussion was deep and compelling"by Sharon49 (see profile) 08/27/08
I completely engrossed after reading the just the first couple of paragraphs. It drained me of multiple emotions on so many levels. The parallel of the main character Jacob to the bibical Jacob is remarkable.... (read more)
"Highly entertaining literary fiction"by cbahm (see profile) 08/27/08
Our book club talked nonstop for an hour and a half on "Water for Elephants," and we agreed it is well written, entertaining, a fast read, and full of richly detailed layers and vivid characters. We particularly... (read more)
"The life of train circus crews with a love story."by teatime (see profile) 08/27/08
A look at circus life in the days of the train circuit. Full of trauma and dark struggles to stay alive without basic human and animal needs. There is stark contrast between the promise of a future in... (read more)
"Loved it from the first page"by claudiakane (see profile) 09/04/08
Wonderful weaving of circus life during youth with that of growing old and memories. Lively discussion and favorable all around.
"Wonderful characters and interesting historically."by DubaiReader (see profile) 09/15/08
I loved this book and have recommended it to several book groups. Very few people have not shared my enjoyment of it.
"An enjoyable thought-provoking book, yet unnecessarily graphic"by iamom05 (see profile) 09/16/08
I really enjoyed most of this book. There were a couple of moments I cried. It also made me laugh. They were the kind of characters you love to love and love to hate. They really develop over the course... (read more)
"I liked this story quite a bit!"by hartleystudio (see profile) 09/16/08
I thought this book was good. It wasn't my favorite book of all time but the characters were terrific and the story telling was really vivid. It was a great escape to a place I would never want to go!... (read more)
"Well written, lots to discuss, and fun to read"by akhains (see profile) 09/17/08
I think we all liked this book and there was so much to talk about. I would definitely recommend it.
"A spellbinding glimpse into love and circus life via protagonist Jacob Jankowski."by dreamutter (see profile) 09/25/08
"Good book club choice"by deb17866 (see profile) 10/01/08
A captivating look at getting old and life in the circus! An interesting mix. The novel jumps back and forth through memories. I got that, I wanted to stay in the past after awhile. Not thrilled with... (read more)
"Wonderful book"by swooten99 (see profile) 10/02/08
This was a very enjoyable book to read. The characters take you though a wide range of emotions, up until the very end.
"Tells a story of a man who lost everything and found himself in the circus world. How one event can change a person's life."by tamie1174 (see profile) 10/08/08
"Jacob Jankowski is living his last years of life in a nursing home. A circus is set up across the street and brings back the story of his life and a much needed change."by staceyjay (see profile) 10/09/08
This is an easy book to read, a page turner. The story is told by Jacob Jankowski, an elderly man in a nursing home. He is lonely and feels some what abandoned by his family. When the circus comes to... (read more)
"Very Enticing."by tat2zie (see profile) 10/10/08
I read this novel very quickly. It is great for recapturing the casual enjoyment for reading for readings-sake.
"A must read! This is one of my all time favorite books, absolutely loved it!"by leecen (see profile) 10/11/08
A was a bit skeptical when I picked up this book. By the second page, I was hooked! This is a great story with wonderfully rich characters. Not only is the love story beautiful and poignant, but I also... (read more)
"Not too impressed"by janjon31 (see profile) 10/15/08
I wasn't that crazy about the book. I thought it was too gawdy and impressed me as being a tough life. Not fit to live with.
"A Well-Told Tale"by donnadeleon (see profile) 10/19/08
An enjoyable and well-researched tale. The setting and characters were wonderfully complex. The 90 year-old Jacob was both believable and likable, and interspersing his story with that of his younger... (read more)
"Left me wanting more."by De66yJ (see profile) 10/21/08
This is a great story about a young man who suddenly lost everything, ran away and unintentionally joined a circus, finds true love, and a life he never knew he had prepared for. I enjoyed going back and... (read more)
"Wonderful novel lent itself to great discussion"by bookgrouplover (see profile) 10/24/08
Our club, like so many others, loved this book. The characters stay with you and the world it creates is unlike others you'll read about. Good discussion, too.
"I thouroughly enjoyed this book and believe it brings many discussion topics to the table"by evamp (see profile) 10/24/08
"great book!"by hruth (see profile) 10/25/08
Captivating, endearing, sad, and happy. The characters are loveable, the plot is unpredictable, the ending is perfect, and it's told from the point of view of an old man in a nursing home. All the components... (read more)
"good discussion book"by DeenaR (see profile) 10/28/08
Some in our club thought it was a little slow at first, but we all warmed up quickly and ended up loving this one. No wonder it's so popular.
"Very Well-Written, Unusual Tale"by BHastings (see profile) 10/29/08
Our club was unanimous on this one, as seems to be the case with most clubs for this book.
"Great book! Awesome to use for discussions."by megfarris (see profile) 10/30/08
We thoroughly enjoyed this book. It is a quick read, interesting, and is great for discussions.
" This is a story of a man who joins a circus and discovers all the inner workings of the life associated with that show."by CarolCunningham (see profile) 10/31/08
I would never have picked this novel myself, but I am so glad that it was a book club pick, because I really enjoyed it!
"Stepping out of my reading comfort zone..."by chelle_osu (see profile) 11/01/08
Water for Elephants is not a book I would have picked to read. Having said that, I enjoyed the book very much. It is not a book that you can't put down, but it is a sometimes funny, quite interesting... (read more)
"Wonderful, riveting story."by goatee125 (see profile) 11/03/08
It is humorous and serious. Great read. Has some vulgar language and descriptive sexual scenes, so not for everyone. Based on fact so is a very believable. I read the entire novel in two days and... (read more)
"read the authors note first, this time I think it makes a difference, I loved the end!!! and our book club had the best descussions from this book, we used some of the questions at the end."by bunny (see profile) 11/03/08
It is a can't wait to get back to my book type of read. I really love the way sara has developed her characters and the struggles, and the beauty at the end of the book. I think her humor with the older... (read more)
"Reminds us each person has an amazing story"by tricia1222 (see profile) 11/08/08
This is great book. One of my top 10 ever. This is an amazing and interesting story of a life fully lived and a the great adventure which sets the protagonist's life on a new track.
"Nice story, well told, not a lot to discuss."by billnesmith (see profile) 11/12/08
Most of the people in our club are looking for more than just a good, heartwarming story for a club book. We want some conflict; ambiguity in character, actions, or motives; or some questions that are... (read more)
"Excellent choice for a book club!"by katkra (see profile) 11/15/08
His was a great book to read. I have a personal fondness for elephants, which made the story that much better, but even despite that it's a great read. There are so many facets to this story that make... (read more)
"Interesting and surprising, making for good discussion. Lots of life's lessons here."by doneilbat (see profile) 11/17/08
"So interesting!"by mgsiragusa (see profile) 11/17/08
I didn't want to read this book in the beginning; I am so glad I did. Interesting, sad, happy - too many emotions to list!
"delightful account of a man's search for adventure and meaning"by rosemaryheller (see profile) 11/23/08
"Great read!"by ShanaM (see profile) 12/05/08
This is one of our groups favorite books. Led to a very interesting discussion....wish we could find more of this caliber!
"We all loved this book!"by aprilkyle (see profile) 12/17/08
Everyone in our book club loved reading this book. The characters are wonderful and we enjoyed being immersed in the circus world. Plus, it has a great ending!!!
"Can be read on several levels."by kim.steele (see profile) 12/21/08
You can read this book as a parable, as a character study, as historical fiction describing the circus during the depression years....the writer is witty, insightful and gives her characters real life... (read more)
"The Circus has never been so exciting before...."by kiffydbrown (see profile) 12/21/08
In this book Sara Gruen takes you on a thrilling train ride with the circus. I have been to the circus before but this book gives you an insight into the circues of the past that you would have never imagined.... (read more)
"The book was well written, kept us fully engaged giving the desire to continue reading."by melodyn (see profile) 12/26/08
After our discussion we found that their was hidden meaning in the incidences that occurred in the book. It gave us much to discuss and learn about other readers perspectives. From the beginning of the... (read more)
"very suspensful and interesting...."by katemurphy (see profile) 12/30/08
A book full of interesting places and people. A read full of suspense and you'll find yourself having a hard time leaving it!. I only gave it 4 stars because it was a little hard to get into but once i... (read more)
"We all loved this. Learned a lot about the circus too which was an added extra"by 090537 (see profile) 01/02/09
"Fantastic and twisting!"by rubyslipper84 (see profile) 01/05/09
I'm not much for a story with animals but this was great! With a sudden twist at the end that you never see coming, I read this within just a few days. Wonderful characters that your heart tugs for. A... (read more)
"Set in the world of the circus through the eyes of Jacob and the amazing elephant he befriends"by sheena09 (see profile) 01/10/09
Fabulous and heart-warming story of a friendship between a man and Rosie the elephant in the old days of the circus.
"This book was one of my favorites for the year!"by eatlizzardsdaily (see profile) 01/13/09
I loved this book. It was different from any book I'd ever read, and it sucked me in.
"The author has done a great job describing life in the circus at that time . Her descriptions of all the characters made their lives so vivid."by greenwave (see profile) 01/14/09
We enjoyed the history and descriptions of the life of those involved with the circus during that period. There was so much to talk about with all the personalities involved. Would recommend it for a... (read more)
"Surprised myself .. loved this book!"by Mairpac (see profile) 01/15/09
I was hesitant to read a book with a Circus background .. not sure I would face cruelty to animals or what type of people I would find in the pages. I ended up loving this peak into life in the Circus... (read more)
"A Historical Fiction book about the circus"by lollygil (see profile) 01/16/09
The background story of a boy who grows up with the circus. It gets behind the sparkle and glamour of the circus.
"Theme of circus and old age cohesively put together in a great story."by Frango (see profile) 01/17/09
I would recommend this book. The history of the traveling circus gives one a picture of a bygone era. The nursing home scenes are most realistic and show how old age depersonalizes one.
"Great read!"by vggordon (see profile) 01/22/09
An extremely well written book. Difficult to read at times if you are an animal lover. I will never go to the circus again!Great story with several story lines.
"Great Book"by jiviro (see profile) 02/01/09
This book was really enjoyed by everyone in our book club. Very interesting details. I wasn't sure we were going to like it, but it turned out to be a favorite! Led to many discussions. Upon our group... (read more)
"Really enjoyable read but not a lot to discuss"by Etain (see profile) 02/01/09
Everyone enjoyed this book for the most part, some enjoyed it more than others. We all agreed it was a really nice fairy tale and a nice simple read. However we thought that for a book club choice it... (read more)
"The journey of a one mans life and how often, life comes full circle."by glkbob (see profile) 02/01/09
Very good. Didn't think I was going to like it, but ended up loving it.
"Interesting setting but not alot to talk about"by nvlehman (see profile) 02/01/09
The circus and historical setting was interesting but the characters were not very well developed and our group found little to talk about.
"True Love Story - One of my favorite books"by Mama_B (see profile) 02/07/09
Catch a glimpse of the behind the scenes of an old time circus. The life, the hierchy, the cruelty, the business, the unwritten rules of a circus is the setting. Throw in a mean boss, a pretty lady, a... (read more)
"Quite a different read..loved it!"by Lv2shop (see profile) 02/08/09
Not a group discussion book but Sara gave a spectacular insight behind the scenes of the circus intertwined with a most unforgettable story. Beautiful ending.... Brilliant!
"It was one of my all time favorite reads."by coedobx5348 (see profile) 02/13/09
Our book club read this in March of last year. It was my selection. We loved the book. It was a great book for discussion also.
"A great story; well researched; really captures the climate of the 30's"by rbruno (see profile) 02/13/09
"water for elephants"by knock3xs (see profile) 02/15/09
One of the best books I've read this year. Even if you don't care for the circus, the characters draw you in and keep you there. A wonderful book.
"an eye opening experience of life in the circus and life in general."by rmbueno8 (see profile) 02/16/09
This book caught my attention from the very beginning. I like the way Sara Gruen went back and forth between Jacob's old age and his younger self. Makes for an interesting read that way.
"Captivating"by margwbl (see profile) 02/25/09
I truly enjoyed this book. After several dry/depressing tomes (hey I read for escape, I don't need to read about depressing childhoods, I lived one! :-))--this came as a breath of fresh air! I typically... (read more)
"Lovely... It is really "nice". It really is refreshing."by tat2zie (see profile) 02/28/09
Honestly, I really enjoyed this. Just enough story... It is ideal for a nice casual read by the fire.
"one of my all time favorites"by carehoff (see profile) 03/01/09
I loved this book! Most of our group liked it. We had a good discussion about this one!
"Vivid! I felt like I was there!"by SebastiansMom (see profile) 03/01/09
I adored this book from the first page. First of all I love animals and who doesn't love a circus? After reading this book it makes me rethink my love for circuses and I visibly cringed at some passages... (read more)
"A very different book - has well developed characters with Jacob being the best"by tmcdanel (see profile) 03/04/09
I never thought a look back at circus life could be such a unique story.
"A story of one man's journey through life as a member of the circus in the 30's"by kdy12570 (see profile) 03/05/09
"Great book"by WPLWBC (see profile) 03/31/09
A great read. The illusion of the "fun" atmosphere of the circus world masks the hardships faced by the characters.
"Great Story - John Irving Light"by seashine (see profile) 04/04/09
This was a great book for discussion. Very engaging story reminiscent of John Irving, but without quite so much angst. Satisfying ending that everyone liked.
"I love Elephants now.."by nikol777 (see profile) 04/16/09
I found the book extremely gripping although I fought reading it every since it came out. I typically stay away from the bestseller bays at the store I work in as they usually are so predictable and "safe"... (read more)
"One of the best books we've read & discussed!"by drobinson (see profile) 04/18/09
Ms. Gruen's writing style provides so much rich imagery that you can just about smell the passing train. :o) We enjoyed the insight into the older Jacob's world, which provided us with a reminder to be... (read more)
"Water for Elephants"by tammyoldghent (see profile) 05/18/09
It made me never want to go to a circus. I liked the very end though....
"The writing is unforced"by BellaBella (see profile) 05/22/09
Gruen's descriptive writing is flowing, vivid, and unforced. Even the personalities of the animals are captured through the description of their body language. The book really comes to life.
"I have always wanted to join the circus...."by danielle_schndr (see profile) 06/04/09
I loved this book. I wanted to keep reading and wanting to know more about the circus and about this man's life.
"One of my favorites"by gebcam92 (see profile) 06/16/09
This is an easy read with such a compelling story I read it in the span of three days! Highly recommend it!
"Water for Elephants"by jillschwadron (see profile) 06/18/09
I compared this book to Cider House Rules at our discussion. It was a "coming of age" story of a young man, his first love and coming to terms with societies rules.
"Colorful language and very addictive"by verheyen1202 (see profile) 06/19/09
Water for Elephants was a fun read with lots of detailed accounts of life in the circus. The end of the book keeps you on your toes until the curtain call.
"Water For Elephants"by Evie (see profile) 06/25/09
A friend recommended this book. It sat on my shelf for a year. I should have started it much earlier. Once I began reading I was very interested in not only the era, the lifestyle but the characters... (read more)
"Water For Elephants"by Marsha1962 (see profile) 06/25/09
This was a real "page turner." Everyone in our clud enjoyed reading it...That's saying a lot. In light of our current economic times this is a great book that lends perspective on difficult ecomonics and... (read more)
"My Favorite"by nr55 (see profile) 06/29/09
This was everyone in my. book club's favorite book so far. It touched everyone differently and it grabbed us all entirely. I have already suggested this book to many other readers
"Surprising gem"by kamj3 (see profile) 07/06/09
I was pleasantly surprised by this book since I wasn't too excited about a "circus" book. The parallels with the biblical story gave it a bit more depth while it remained an easy and entertaining read.... (read more)
"Like Water for Elephants"by annwellman (see profile) 07/17/09
This is a book I never would have picked out myself. However, after reading the book, I am happy to report it is one of the best books I have ever read. I absolutley loved it and couldn't put it down.... (read more)
"Water for Elephants"by cjdeboer (see profile) 07/18/09
This is a great book for discussion groups. You have got to try it.
"A captivating story line"by katemurphy (see profile) 07/18/09
Really great read, I was a little worried with the title and the cover of the book... but overall it was a really great book!
"Surprised me!"by ginamc04 (see profile) 07/19/09
I didnt think I'd like this book because I generally like books based on women's friendships-but I truely loved this story
"too much violence for me"by shelbymomof2 (see profile) 07/22/09
Although I liked the historical setting, there was too much violence in this book for my taste, violence toward people, women, and animals. Outside of the violence, it was interesting.
"Water for Elephants"by kaco (see profile) 07/24/09
The storyline picks you up at the beginning and you don't want to stop until the end. And the ending makes the whole story worth it.
"One of our book club favorities."by ColleenD (see profile) 08/05/09
Everyone in the club loved this one and we had a good discussion.
"Easy summer read"by cleothekat (see profile) 08/12/09
I really liked this book. It was easy to read and drew me in from the very beginning. I felt the circus background was really interesting and something new.
"compelling, interesting characters and story"by holland (see profile) 09/12/09
a wonderful story. water for elephants is more than, but also as plain as, the history of a circus vet, recalled from a senior care facility. it is not, however, simple. the characters and plots of... (read more)
"A Great Surprise"by DianeParfitt (see profile) 09/15/09
This book was a delightful surprise to read. The characters were wonderful, the story kept your attention and the animals touched your heart. A completely new look at the circus world.
"Water for Elephants"by weisswitch (see profile) 09/15/09
Remarkable craftsmanship, graphic cruelty both to animals and humans, but interesting insights into the traveling circuses of our childhood.
"Water for Elephants"by csparks (see profile) 09/19/09
This was a breath-taking mystery and we had so many feelings at the end about the dead friend, who killed the head of the circus, the poor elephant that did not speak English, etc. Most of us are older... (read more)
"Why Did I Wait So Long"by mizbilli (see profile) 09/23/09
I bought this book and it sat on my reading shelf for over a year, then after hearing a couple of friends talking about it, I picked it up....and wonder what was I thinking and WHY did I wait so long.... (read more)
"Water For Elephants"by EDiggins48 (see profile) 09/25/09
Utterly interesting. Completely worth every minute of reading. Wonderful Ending!
"Water for Elephants was Great!"by lnfitz (see profile) 09/25/09
The story starts with a very enigmatic prologue and then comes back full circle with a knockout ending. The twist will have you very surprised!
"Water for Elephants"by eshiner (see profile) 10/15/09
good book, I like how the main character drifted back and forth from past to present. The story made me sad and anxious while I was reading, which caused me to need to continue then the mood or setting... (read more)
"Water for Elephants"by barbra (see profile) 11/02/09
Fabulous book. I intend to re-read it. Book Club loved it.
"A fascinating read..."by stacifw (see profile) 11/05/09
I loved this book. It was not the type of book I usually read but I am so glad that I read it:) I was taken back by the ruthless shown to the animals. But loved how Rosie took care of business.
"Water For Elephants"by lisapence (see profile) 11/12/09
I've always been fascinated with the elderly. They each have their very own lifestory to tell. It is very interesting to hear this mans story of being in the circus in the early 1900's. It is written... (read more)
